Note that I said, "meeting." I didn't consider initial meetings "dates" which took lots of pressure off. I thought of OKCupid as a way to meet women who seemed interesting and who I might end up being interested in dating.
I was able to meet 1-2 women a week, usually for coffee, tea, or a walk in the park. Most of the time it was just a nice conversation and we went our separate ways. A few I became friends with, a few I dated, and in the end I met my partner of going on 5 years now.
Here are my tips: 1) Put minimal energy into each message. Say hi, acknowledge you read their profile, and ask a question. 2) Set up a real life meeting quickly. If I got a response, my second message would ask if they wanted to get together for coffee/whatever. 3) Include as little information as possible in your profile. Dont try to be funny or over share. It just a gives people a reason to reject you.