And it happens to be mine, also, in regard to the SoundCloud samples. Sure, the project behind it might be mathematically interesting and all... but really now, this ain't music, let alone jazz. In fact, if I came across those samples whilst flipping between radio stations, I would probably hover for at most a second or two, before giving the dial another turn... or turning the damn thing off.
Absolutely unlistenable, in other words.
Your comment, on the other hand, provided some more insight into why this might not be notable or impressive.
Your comment on the other hand (aside the complaining about downvoting, which is discouraged in the HN guidelines) was fair and interesting - and I personally upvoted it.
1. I heard more convincing music composed by AI a decade ago. 2. It suffers from the same pointlessness that seems to plague these attempts: Disjointed, monotonous, doesn't go anywhere. 3. The exercise did not place itself in the context of other approaches to AI music compodituon. I apologize for my rudeness and brevity.
So it does the usual expert system/AI thing of cycling between "Almost music" and "And... lost the plot" over and over.
If it learned from a real musician, one of the first things it would have been taught is how to listen to other musician's music. And then, how to listen to itself. And then, how to play a much simpler piece, than then play it right, so it sounds like music... not like someone typing (which is what the SoundCloud samples sound like, to my ears).
But of course machines don't "listen" in any meaningful sense. And they certainly can't tell what it is they like about Pat Metheny's music; or why they "like" his music, but not the music of Billy Joel or Anthony Braxton.
So maybe that's where these researchers should start -- by creating systems that (at least attempt to) understand and evaluate music. And to tell good from bad.
Then, maybe, they can toy around with systems that generate music.
(and yet is still more human-sounding than the atonalism that dominates modern orchestra works)
Like pretty much exactly what you'd expect coming from an an entity or a thing that thinks music is just about notes and mathematical patterns... and not about emotions, or an experience that you feel in your body.
On a less handy-wavy level, I suspect there are issues of tone and timing embedded in human-generated musical expression that these algorithms don't begin to capture. In the same way that - no matter how much they keep tweaking their markov chains and phoneme scales -- we can always tell that a machine-generated voice sounds "off" somehow, literally within tens of milliseconds.
As the saying goes: it don't mean thing if it ain't got that je n'sais quoi.