At 4GB, I'd agree with you. But I'm still running my 2009 (!!!!!!!) MBP with 8GB RAM, and it's fine. And no doubt, the new MacBook is a bajillion times faster than my somehow-increasingly-heavier-each-year-brick-of-aluminum MBP and will handle memory pressure like a champ.
And speaking of memory pressure, for it's intended use, even with 30 Chrome tabs, 8GB is fine. Plus, given Apple's track record of device support over the last 7 or 8 years, Apple intends this machine to be usable for at least 3 years.
Seriously thinking it may finally be the year I upgrade -- I will miss the matte screen though.
The extra RAM has some big disadvantages:
1. As I recall, I lost about 40 minutes run time on batteries.
2. It decreases battery sleep time. Prior to the upgrade, I could go for 4 or 5 days in sleep, and still have useful enough battery life. Now it is more like 2 or 3 days.
3. It dramatically increases time to sleep and wake from sleep.
4. It eats valuable SSD space. You need 16GB to sleep. And you swap files will be bigger. You likely need a bigger SSD to support the RAM
5. RAM does cost money up front.
If you do need 16GB, you know it and should be ready for these trade offs. As someone who regularly runs 2 or 3 browsers, Mac and Linux development tools, MS Office, Adobe, Linux and Windows VMs, etc, I am in the class of people who need the extra RAM. Most people do not.
However, "Sleep" on MacBooks is a combination of what people commonly refer to as Sleep and Hibernation
I believe that the current method is to Sleep the system with both keeping the RAM powered AND write RAM to the drive. If there is enough battery, the system will wake fast by using the current RAM, if the battery dies, it recovers from the RAM image stored on drive.
This works well for most people using base configurations. For those of us using the limits of the hardware, it might not give the preferred results. There are various GUI and CLI tools such as SmartSleep to control Sleep and Hibernate based on your preferences and taking into consideration the current battery level.
And, as another bonus, I have a "Click to Hibernate" feature that I've been wanting for a long time. My return from hibernation is very fast, and, in theory, the battery loss should be fairly minimal while in a hibernate state.
SmartSleep does add a significant trick, it allows you to automatically change the mode based on the current battery level.
1: https://developer.apple.com/library/mac/documentation/Darwin...
I haven't experimented with using it to try and keep a machine running with the lid closed, however - that's traditionally considered risky for heat reasons.
However, I was surprised at how much work I was still able to do. I felt the slowness of the CPU far more than the limited RAM.
I am happy to be back to 16GB except when I look at battery life. And I could adapt to less RAM.
I'm guessing that SSDs and swapping really changed the game around virtual memory performance on Mac laptops.
Well, yeah. This thread is centered around laptops, after all.
Well, I'll have to call BS on that. It maybe increase it, but hardly "dramatically". In fact time to sleep/wake is fast enough to barely care about it.
And I have 16GB RAM and the older, 2013 era, SSDs. Newer MBP SSDs are 2x-3x the speed of mine.
Plus, since then Apple added memory compression...
That and I'm a bit heavy on the tab (ab)use.
Now I did do the RAM and SSD upgrades at the same time. I went from 8GB of RAM and a 250GB SSD.
I remember spending some time trying to figure out why wake/sleep times where so hugely increased. I could never pin it down exactly, but I strongly suspect it was related to the RAM increase.
OS X really does work miracles with virtual memory - my 16 GiB Windows 7 machine starts spinning up and swapping if I leave google earth running in it overnight. And next morning - there is always a 60 second pause while everything swaps back in...
Of course, some people get crazy and have like 60-70 tabs open, that's just not my flow.
[1] http://www.apple.com/pr/library/2016/04/19Apple-Updates-MacB...