[0]https://www3.epa.gov/otaq/documents/nonroad/420f14017.pdf
When the sales guy told me the tank only had to be filled at service intervals, it sounded strange. People on the TDI forums thought it was just because VW didn't want to scare away customers with an extra thing to do, but you can buy the stuff at any gas station and pouring it into the tank is not difficult.
When the scandal broke the assumption was that they mistuned the DEF cars out of arrogance, and again to avoid spooking customers with extra maintenance.
Now it sounds much more like they tuned it that way because this regulation would have crippled the car with an enormous DEF tank otherwise. It is possible that such a regulation combined with a 10,000 mile service interval only makes engineering sense on mid-size trucks or larger.
This doesn't have anything to do with them failing to build a working LNT solution and cheating with those previously, of course.
If you think that's a problem, then please explain why this isn't also a problem for the gas tank. I don't know of any cars which will continue to drive (but spewing extra toxins) when the gas or diesel tank is empty.
Customers don't seem to have much of a problem topping up their diesel tank every week or two....
And actually I'm not so quick to assume this is only a stupid decision either. Hanlon's razor still applies but there is also a distinct possibility that this regulation was "encouraged" as a play to make small diesel cars less competitive.
VW doesn't want their cars going into limp mode. They don't want customers calling up asking why their car is acting funny. They don't want to increase the maintenance load on their customers. They don't want customers coming in for unnecessary service appointments (especially for stuff they wouldn't be able to charge for). Making a tank big enough to last as long as the motor oil seems like an easy, low tech solution. Sometimes simple is better.
After hearing about this regulation it seems an obvious reason why they would keep the cheat enabled even after adding a DEF system.
It is feasible and they already do it.
Or do you mean the Chevy Cruze? They must have some strategy that works (so far).
Some of the VWs are getting bigger DEF tanks. For the cars that this isn't an option, I don't think VW has said exactly what they are going to do. They could just disable the cheating mode on the software. Fuel economy and performance would suck, but the emissions would be at acceptable levels.
There's been a lot of speculation all along, will they retrofit DEF systems, will the cars just get super unreliable because the systems can't handle prolonged legal operation, etc.
2013-2014 cars need to hold 1/2 gallon more exhaust fluid and apparently that's doable (and also new firmware).
Older cars are a bigger problem and will likely get a combination of fixes but in the end, they are going to be louder, fuel hungry cars after getting "fixed".
The oldest cars will likely get owners a buy-back offer because the depreciated value is lower than the cost to fix.
And what exactly will this firmware tweak do? If it decreases performance or fuel economy, then that isn't acceptable. The customer bought the car because it advertised X horsepower and Y mpg; if the firmware tweak changes that, then that's false advertising and the company needs to refund their money in full.
What's really stupid is that it sounds like they should be able to get the advertised power and economy with the required low emissions simply by using more DEF. I'm assuming the DEF liquid isn't too expensive here, but if they just made it so you needed to refill it every 1000 miles, that should solve the problem. Heck, why can't they just make it available at gas stations too?
Having this idiotic notion that only dealers should be able to refill the stuff, and that it needs to be done at 10k intervals, is what's making it impossible.
Why not require that cars must be able to carry enough fuel to drive 10,000 miles while they're at it? It makes as much sense.