Microsoft shafts HTC phone users
theinquirer.net
theinquirer.net
FTA: "the HD2 meets many of the criteria laid down in Microsoft's 'Chassis 1' specifications. After all it has a 1GHz Qualcomm processor, a high-res capacitive touch display, a 5 megapixel camera and 3.5mm headphone jack. However it turns out that the phone has five buttons instead of the three blessed by the Vole's CEO Steve Ballmer."
The HD2 is more than capable of running WinMo 7. In fact, if you loved WinMo, the HD2 would be (and still is) the phone to buy. Microsoft is sticking it to the fans who really love their stuff here (I work with a lot of Windows professionals and they're the hardcore WinMo fans - most of whom control the messaging environment in their offices).
"There could be more to this than just the sin of having two buttons too many, however: Tony Wilkinson, Business Operations Director for Microsoft Australia, told APC that “there are some hardware components that the HD doesn’t have”."
So there are apparently valid hardware reasons to not allow an upgrade.
1. http://apcmag.com/microsoft-no-windows-phone-7-upgrade-for-w...
The first Windows 7 phone has more than 3 buttons.
I see Microsoft as following Microsoft's playbook for devices. On the desktop their mantra was backwards compatibility, backwards compatibility, backwards compatibility and that worked for them. But on devices, they are far more liberal. PlaysForSure is a good example, they threw their users and partners overboard when they released Zune.
They finally realized the same approach might not work on mobile, the experience is more closely tied to the physical hardware then the desktop or even laptop experience will ever be.
Killing the current Windows Mobile (6.5) is the best move for MS, as was killing PlaysForSure. If you just try to make everyone happy you end up making no-one happy.
This was the point when they realised their desktop strategy of creating an OS for multiple commodity hardware manufacturers wasn't working in the mobile device space.
Windows Phone 7 Series is just taking the Zune and turning it into a phone. Which again, is copying Apple's iPod -> iPhone strategy and adding the odd compromise of still having multiple commodity manufacturers but constraining them all to producing near identical devices.
I see Microsoft as still compromising left right and centre, trying to get hardware manufacturers to play pricing Seppeku. The one thing they have in common with Apple is taking a technically reasonable product--Zune--and rebranding it with a more marketable product's name.
Aplle did this when they bought NeXT and rebranded it as mac OS X!
Apple didn't licence iPod to other manufactures. Microsoft did. Then it abandoned that approach and built the Zune in what was at the time a fairly major turnaround for them and instead copied the iPod model.
I don't follow the Zune too closely, but it is still only built and sold directly by Microsoft isn't it? Just like the iPod, and unlike the previous devices in the PlaysForSure family. The whole point of that branding being that the music, bought from multiple stores, would play on multiple devices, made by different manufacturers (notably not including Apple).
Ouch for the HD2 owners, who had read rumours to the contrary. Well, there's http://wiki.xda-developers.com/index.php?pagename=HTC_Leo
What I meant is that there are alternate ROMs "cooked" by other developers, which may allow for things like running Android ...
That may be an out for people who got an HD2 (nice hardware) in hopes of good evolution on the WinMobile front. Seems the HD2 was good enough to demo the new version, but is getting kicked to the kerb.