Charging for API usage isn't as profitable as selling your users to advertisers. Otherwise twitter would already be living just off of selling the firehose.
I value websites with heavy advertising to be less attractive to me and less valuable. As more users get turned off, the websites will be able to get less money from advertisers.
It can become a snowball effect that kills a service.
https://medium.com/@robleathern/people-in-silicon-valley-don...