> Walking down the street, do you have any trouble telling which buildings are legal to access and which are not?
Do you expect the same response to hacking your local computer club as hacking the IRS?
There are more than one set of social norms on the internet.
The "I know it when I see it" test is useless because it does nothing in the cases where you actually need the test to decide anything. There was never any question what happens to someone who hacks the DoD and sells secrets to the Russians -- you don't need any kind of computer-specific laws for that because it's illegal regardless of how you do it.
The problem cases are the ones where the argument is over whether permission was implicit vs. absent vs. not required. For example, should it be illegal for a journalist to access internal documents a company published on their website but probably didn't intend to? What if the journalist has to guess the URL? And those seem to be exactly the sort of cases that can be charged only under the CFAA and not any other law.
> Some people resist this clear social norm in cyber-space. They want to posit a "right to tinker" or a "right to explore." It is that resistance that creates uncertainty, not the law.
A law the relies on social norms adopts the uncertainty inherent in the social norms. In the context of the internet where all cultures are together in the same "space" this gives the law more than the usual amount of uncertainty.
Which makes the problem one that is much easier to solve technically than legally. If you in fact prevent unauthorized access using technical means then there is no occasion to resort to legal process or contend with the uncertainty of differing social norms, which is already inherently necessary for extrajurisdictional attackers who aren't subject to legal process regardless.
And if the problem can (and for foreign attackers must) be addressed mainly through technical means then the justification for uncertain laws with harsh penalties is significantly eroded, while the cost in terms of chilling effects and potential for abuse is not reduced at all.