I wonder if you would compare/contrast with short selling UPRO ?
That is, short selling the triple-long S&P 500 ETF.
The thinking here is that a long ETF (especially a triple long one) loses value every single day[1] due to the natural decay of long ETFs ...
So in a flat market, your short position is positive, and in down markets it is very positive. Further, it's not an option - you're simply short an ETF - so you can hold it through a market rally if you wanted to.
I have never employed this hedge, but it interests me.
[1] except for up-market days, of course ...