Your PhD scholarship idea would see similar issues, including unforeseen bottlenecks which would starve out existing worthy research -- not just in this field but others too.
I think Ellison is right to be very particular about where he spends his money.
Similarly, you are more likely to "hit the high notes" in research by concentrating effort in a few places. The alternative is lots of duplicated efforts that each don't quite achieve anything.
This applies especially to medical research where the barriers to getting meaningful clinical results are sky high.
If you are advocating that the best Universities deserve a higher share of funding I don't disagree but there are plenty of great scientists that started at what you might judge as lesser Universities. To give them nothing would be an error.
I think your numbers are off by a couple orders of magnitude.
This made it sound like he would be hiring PhDs. If he gave a scholarship to 100,000 PhDs, very few of them would end up working on anything related to extending Larry Ellison's life.
You seem confused about the terminology. I think you meant "PhD candidates". If you're talking about "hiring a PhD", this is a person who has earned his/her PhD and is in the field. A postdoc is specifically a person still pursuing additional research at an educational institution, still working with a faculty mentor, and usually alongside PhD candidates and other postdocs.
You don't give a scholarship to someone with a PhD. You give them a salary or a grant and occasionally an award or a bursary or a fellowship. You are arguing for the <1% case when someone has chosen a poor, confusing sounding moniker for what is essentially one of these other things.
This doesn't seem like a property of capitalism at all. In fact, doing this research through university seems to run against capitalist principles. If it was done privately there would be no obligation to share any of the outcomes.
Edit: like the other comment 'Larry Ellison has cancer'; that's exactly the reason he would do this...
"Money doesn't mean that much to me," Ellison said, according to Agus. "I want to see progress" in cancer research.