Only by truly decadent standards could an income of $125,000 be said to "definitely suck". $125k is 2.4x median income and puts you in the 97th percentile of all American workers.
Only by truly decadent standards could an income of $125,000 be said to "definitely suck". $125k is 2.4x median income and puts you in the 97th percentile of all American workers.
I presented three fictional "couples" and their career choices that would easily get you to the $125,000 point in today's labor market. None of these pairing would be considered "highly compensated" or upper class. Middle class would be a more appropriate designation.
With regards to the "suck" factor - try running a household in SF, LA, or NYC (with kids and spouse) on that amount. I don't think owning my own home and having good schools is a particularly decadent expectation. Or having good access to health care and support services. Nor should I be expected to leverage myself to the eyeballs to buy a starter home.
Would think that the expectation of a professional earning that amount is that they are providing their kids with an environment where their kids can replicate their success.
I make right around $125k and live in SF. I have the luxury of not having to think much about how I spend my money, and yet I still have $2000-$3000 left over every single month. For perspective, half of all Americans would not be able to afford a single unexpected $400 expense[1]. That's what definitely sucks, not the fact that I can't afford a house in Bernal Heights.
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/the-fix/wp/2015/06/03/tn...
This is an argument that can be made at virtually any income level. Consider the following article and this really charming infographic they put together:
http://www.wsj.com/articles/six-figure-incomesand-facing-fin...
http://si.wsj.net/public/resources/images/BF-AE118B_05WIc_G_...
(infographic from http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB100014241278873236896045782201...)
After all - $400k isn't really that much, after you've paid taxes and put away $22k per year for retirement and the kids' college, and after you're done spending $87k per year on a mortgage, $25k per year on property taxes, $40k per year on maintenance and utilities, $30k per year on groceries, $21k per year on dining out, $26k per year on vacations, $24k per year on car expenses, $12k on country club dues, $10k per year on children's sports, and $9k per year on gifts and donations. Why in fact you're $10k in the hole!
I don't quite know how to say this other than bluntly, but $125k is a long ways above median household income everywhere in the country. For comparison, the median household income for New York City is $50,711 and the median household income for the San Francisco Metro Area is $83,222. Most people live off less than $125k, don't pretend it's impossible. Expenses tend to find a way to encompass available income unless you make a deliberate effort to stop that - even for people making $400k per year.
$125k isn't "rich" in the sense that you could quit working and live off the income from your investments or commute every weekend from your villa in the Caribbean, but it's vastly more than most people will ever see, and it's enough to be totally financially secure _if you choose to be_.
This is really the distinction the article is getting at: some people use "lower/middle/upper" in the sense of income quantiles, other people use it in the sense of working-vs-rentier classes (i.e. proletariat-vs-bourgeois). But there's always been a group of HENRYs - Marx labelled them as the "petit bourgeois".
However, I'm generally in agreement with the post. I live in a relatively unfashionable neighborhood south of 280 in SF. Dumping and graffiti are common, front easements (yards) are paved over for extra parking or broken down car storage (illegally, but with extremely indifferent enforcement). Local schools aren't highly ranked in terms of test scores (though this doesn't matter all that much in SF, which is run by lottery much to the chagrin of people who live in higher performing districts). It would be very, very difficult to buy into this neighborhood in SF on $125k a year. You'd have trouble buying for much under a mil. On two incomes you can, but keep in mind, child care runs about $25k per year per kid, and even with kids in SFUSD ("free"), you have to pay extra for after care and summer camps, which will run you about 10k per kid per year even if you're doing things relatively cheaply (YMCA or SF park and rec run programs). At "upper class" incomes, you will lose the tax break for these things, so the second spouse needs to make a substantial salary before things get better financially.
Does living here "suck" by global standards of poverty? No way, not even slightly. Is it the kind of "upper class" life you'd expect for a dual income household of highly educated and skilled workers living in ground zero for a severe labor shortage for wildly profitable companies?
San Francisco is wonky, but keep in mind, the companies that say that there is a severe shortage of workers often do demand that their workers live out here, so the $125k salary really should be considered in the context of SF or NY level housing prices.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_income_in_the_United..., link to actual census results in footer.
Since we tax labor and we don't tax land, this raises the suck factor. $125k in Northern Alabama probably means a darn good living. In SanFran? Probably not.
Also, Dallas used to be the place where land was cheap(er) and jobs paid relatively well, but that ended after Enron.