> if we have to recompile and redistribute all the dependent packages for every OpenSSL upgrade anyway?
Because we don't – look at how many updates Debian, Red Hat, etc. have shipped for OpenSSL vs. the number of times you've had to recompile dependent packages.
OpenSSL is also something an outlier because it's both critically exposed for security and has a somewhat unusual development model, so it's also important to remember that even if it _was_ true that we have to rebuild OpenSSL callers regularly, that's manifestly not true of the hundreds of other libraries where dynamic linking saves time and memory.