Yes, that's my point. Not every one agrees with this and GGP's comment doesn't mention this fact.
So pointing out examples [..] contributes little to the discussion.
It adds examples of US protectionism so you can compare them with the ones from China that were mentioned before. Hopefully, this contributes to a more objective point of view. Why do I need to justify this?
And we're still left with examples of Chinese internet industry protectionism.
The US complaining about China's protectionism is hypocritical. Let's talk about America's farm subsidies. How is that not competing unfairly? It leads to American agricultural produce being dumped on foreign markets at subsidized prices, destroying entire countries' agricultural base. What would you say is the degree of protectionism here?
> pointing out examples of a nation engaging in protectionism contributes little to the discussion unless you compare it to other nations.
1. I would have thought post-"corn-syrup-gate" more Americans would at least know corn is heavily subsidized.
5 seconds of Google searching reveals a long lists of results:
https://www.google.com/#q=chinese+agricultural+subsidies
http://www.economist.com/news/china/21651272-others-cut-farm...
Agricultural subsidies are really not going to support your point. Most countries have heavy agricultural subsidies.
I'm not saying that these subsidies are necessary; I'm just saying that they should be analyzed with a different framework.
Being self sufficient for war and producing excess agriculture product and dumping it on foreign markets are two completely different things.
And two can play at that game - china can make the same 'national security' nonsense argument about information espionage when it comes to the internet.
And in the modern world - the internet is more useful then food for a nation state - america can lose 30 million people and still win a total war as long as its nukes are functional.
Its all about protectionism.
However, software and hardware on one hard, and internet on another, aren't the same thing: I don't see how one can seriously make the same argument in favor of great chinese firewall. It's only effective against general population, and doesn't seriously negate any cyber-threats, as far as I understand.
Hell, we don't even have to imagine — remember testing JS on every browser around 2007?
For the F-35 program, it contains a lot of technology which can't be found anywhere else in the world, and much of that technology was funded by the US government. For all the ridicule the project got, the corresponding projects in Russia and China are even worse off... If anything, the F-35 program is overpriced because there are no reasonable adversaries.
Isn't SpaceX substantially cheaper than any other alternative at this point?