This is actually quite usable, but on about 3% of websites, it doesn't work. These site are usually those horrible abomination of bloat-pages that, for no good reason whatsoever, need javascript files from 20 different domains in order to display a static page (I'm looking at you, Wired.com). In these cases, it becomes too tedious to pick the domains that should be whitelisted.
Most times, I simply close the offending website. In the rare case that I actually want to visit the site, I temporarily switch to Chrome.
I still go through the hassle of using NoScript, because it un-breaks pages that would otherwise for no good reason whatsoever decide it's OK to intercept common key combinations (CTRL+t), disable right-clicks, serve pop-ups, pop-overs, or pop-unders, start playing videos or sound without me asking for that thank you very much, or generally try to hijack my browser, my data, or my computer.