Will Yammer fail because of the constraints of the enterprise?
radar.oreilly.com
radar.oreilly.com
The most interesting thing here for me is the articulation of the difference between the buyer (IT guys) and the users (employees). This is the central problem with enterprise software I think, and the reason that the field lags behind consumer software in innovation.
We use Yammer enterprise wide. It is wildly successful. Even if a lot of the information shared is publicly available, that by itself is ground-breaking, as we have so many business units that knowing who just released a new product based on X is enlightening. As for sharing proprietary information, it's a a common sense filter that is easily applied whether it is ok to redistribute something from a Yammer update. If in doubt, don't.
You might dismiss Yammer as a Twitter clone but Yammer was smart enough to realize the Fortune 500/Enterprise market wanted a hosted, secure solution.
Ps- Yes I know small and medium sized businesses have their own problems, but they have the path of least resistance.