"Circumventing payment" really is not in this case. It's the other half of the price-finding mechanism in the marketplace for content, which is suspiciously missing from option 1 above. Every price is negotiable, and in this case some small segment of the target audience is offering $0 for the content.
By your logic, it's immoral to mute the TV, go to the kitchen, and make a sandwich during the commercial break. In reality, some percentage of the population makes sandwiches instead of watching ads, and this behavior is priced into the advertising contracts.