The curious case of the weapon that didn't exist
publicmedievalist.com
publicmedievalist.com
He talks about: the name of the weapon; how the weapon may have worked; the veracity of the historical evidence for its existence; and its effectiveness, based on historical evidence, speculation and live action role-playing experience.
In particular, from his communications with the Metropolitan Museum it appears the examples in their collection are likely forgeries from a later era.
His general conclusion is that it may have existed, but if it did it wasn't very popular and almost certainly not very good.
This just screams "No true scotsman" to me. Give an example of a flail and, well, it's not a TRUE flail because...
The paintings of flails aren't TRUE flails because...
The example of a physical flail isn't a TRUE flail because...
The last time I saw someone actually minutely go through all the evidence and point by point address why it must be dismissed, it was in a flat-Earth video. Seriously. "Where's there's smoke, there's fire" exists because if you can show flails all over the historical record then there were probably flails.
Look at this quote from the article:
>“But wait,” you may ask, “what about those flails at the Met that you just mentioned?” This is where the story gets interesting. My working hypothesis is that all the flails at the Met, and those in similar collections occasionally found elsewhere in the world, are, as Warner asserted so bluntly, fakes.
Well, actually this makes it really easy to be a flat-Earth apologist.
"What about the NASA missions, people going to orbit and seeing the Earth? Faked, forgeries. Done in a studio. People have been painting for millennia, it's just that now it's digital. What about the fact that you can talk to someone in China or Australia and ask them about where the sun is? They're lying or simply mistaken. How can they be mistaken about whether it's day or night? Concussion, dementia, practical joke, etc. Point is it's fake. Okay what about the fact that ships disappear hull-first as they recede into the distance? Optical illusion or a trick of the eye. Not real. Okay, what about satellites, GPS? Fake, a forgery. It's easy to come up with a fake system, you could do it on your own computer, you could model a fake "planet" that is a sphere a hundred times the size of earth and make a fake "GPS" system that reports fake values. But why would anyone do that? I don't know, why would anybody fake a flail."
--
EDIT: I don't know why you guys are downvoting me. When authors write provocative pieces purporting that something never existed at all, they're almost always wrong. Example: http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/07/27/joe-goulds-teet...
[Here's Mitchell later on: "In 1964 Mitchell published the second of two profiles of Gould for The New Yorker, later collected in the 1965 book Joe Gould's Secret. Mitchell asserted that the Oral History never existed. Upon the publication of Mitchell's "Joe Gould’s Secret," in September, 1964, people began to write to him and send him notebook copies of the Oral History. "I wish I had had this information when I wrote the second Profile," Mitchell told people who wrote to him, "and if I ever write another article about Joe Gould, which I may do, I’d like very much to have a talk with you.""]
Please see my reply below for where our author uses the same very extreme viewpoint.
or write "the flail was almost certainly an invention of the imaginations of later people."
or write "My working hypothesis is that all the flails [...] are [...] fakes."
or write "At first that would seem to settle the debate: flails certainly existed, otherwise what could these artists be doing putting them in their art?" (The answer is "depictions of the exotic or fantastical" and the author says: "The artist certainly had quite an imagination.")
Why would the author write: "The more interesting possibility is that they were figments of an active artistic imagination, and that the examples we have are artistic or ornamental."
and "the original inventors were not weaponsmiths but illustrators"
i.e. that not one authentic copy exists. That it was invented in art. This is an absolutely ridiculous suggestion, but it is the title and hypothesis of the writeup. The author is suggesting, explicitly in the quotes I mention above, that not one authentic copy had been originally constructed. (Not that it existed but in low numbers, this is an idea he tried very hard to dismiss.)
http://www.metmuseum.org/toah/hd/rogr/hd_rogr.htm
"In the late fourth century B.C., the Romans initiated a policy of expansion that in 300 years made them the masters of the Mediterranean world. Impressed by the wealth, culture, and beauty of the Greek cities, victorious generals returned to Rome with booty that included works of art in all media. Soon, educated and wealthy Romans desired works of art that evoked Greek culture. To meet this demand, Greek and Roman artists created marble and bronze copies of the famous Greek statues. Molds taken from the original sculptures were used to make plaster casts that could be shipped to workshops anywhere in the Roman empire, where they were then replicated in marble or bronze. Artists used hollow plaster casts to produce bronze replicas. Solid plaster casts with numerous points of measurement were used for marble copies. Since copies in marble lack the tensile strength of bronze, they required struts or supports, which were often carved in the form of tree trunks, figures, or other kinds of images.
[...]
All the marble statues in the central area of the Mary and Michael Jaharis Gallery at the Metropolitan Museum are copies made during the Roman period, dating from the first century B.C. through the third century A.D. They replicate statues made by Greek artists some 500 years earlier during the fifth and fourth centuries B.C. "
So those are replicas, made around, say, 200 AD, of statues from 500 years earlier. For us, both times are antiquity.
But this is different. Our author is saying the originals simply didn't exist at all. In fact, in addition to the quotes in my other reply, he explicitly says (other than titling the piece "the curious case of the of the weapon that didn't exist") :
> The more interesting possibility is that they were figments of an active artistic imagination, and that the examples we have are artistic or ornamental. This is a fascinating possibility, because it means that the flail could be an example of what French philosopher Jean Baudrillard called simulacra: copies of something that had no original.
> If it is a simulacrum, the original inventors were not weaponsmiths but illustrators. The weaponsmiths who made them—in the sixteenth, nineteenth, or twenty-first century, were just copying an idea rather than a thing. Its realest life has been its afterlife.
You see the difference? He's saying they're "copies of something that had no original."
So this is very, very different. He is really striving hard to say that the original simply did not exist. At all.
See my other comment for the quotes in which he says this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11745174
The author goes too far.
When authors write provocative pieces purporting that something never existed at all, they're almost always wrong.
I've read the case for Jesus never existed at all and I find it very convincing.
Actually that's a great example. You've been duped! There's mounds and mounds of historical documentation. Jesus was executed at the height of the Roman empire. He had followers, and numerous persons wrote accounts of his teachings.
There is a helluvalot of smoke there. The idea that such a historical person didn't exist AT ALL is a fantastic example.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Historicity_of_Jesus
That says "There is 'near universal consensus' among biblical scholars that Jesus existed historically" and this extends to critics -- "with very few exceptions, such critics generally do support the historicity of Jesus."
See this question:
https://www.quora.com/Are-there-any-Roman-documents-that-tel...
As for the Wikipedia sources, in particular: "Roman historian Tacitus referred to 'Christus' and his execution by Pontius Pilate in his Annals (written ca. AD 116), book 15, chapter 44. The very negative tone of Tacitus' comments on Christians make the passage extremely unlikely to have been forged by a Christian scribe. The Tacitus reference is now widely accepted as an independent confirmation of Christ's crucifixion[...]"
Look, 116 years ago is the same as 1900 is to us. The idea that a historian would just completely fabricate what happened just 116 years earlier during a highly literate time in an administrative empire at its height is absolutely ludicrous.
You should read up about the historicity of Jesus, since that article says there is nearly universal consensus that such a person existed. Look, claiming that he didn't is like me claiming that there is no such person as Joseph Smith who ever existed at all - that he was invented by the Mormons (Church of Latter Day Saints). Joseph Smith was born in 1805 and is the founder of the Mormon church.
You know, I bet I could get a lot of pageviews if I claimed that Joseph Smith simply didn't exist at all, and was "simply a fabrication" of the Mormon church almost a hundred years later. I could use the very same techniques that I'm calling out here.
You want me to do it? Put up a page claiming that Joseph Smith never existed and see if I can get pageviews? Because that is a lot harder to do today than with ancient sources, since the 1800s are so close to our times - but I bet I could still do it.
You simply fell victim to the storytelling ploy of claiming someone or something simply didn't exist at all, and coming up with various explanations for everything about the fact that he did exist.
(Likewise, consider how much ample, ample, record there is of Shakespeare of Stratford-Upon-Avon, including his leaving that town and coming back a rich man. We literally have a copy of his will. The people who claim he was someone entirely different have a TON to explain and do so using some of the same techniques. Well, why didn't whoever Shakespeare WAS continue to publish after Shakespeare's death? I mean, he's so incredibly well-documented. It's nearly certain that Shakespeare was really...wait for it... Shakespeare.)
Anytime you see someone going through all sorts of contortions to explain how a ton of facts, really aren't -- your alarm bells should be going off. Why? For the same reason you were duped by the idea that there was no historical jesus at all. It makes for an amazing story.
I could write, today, an amazing story about how Joseph Smith didn't exist at all. True, I'd have a ton of explaining to do. It would be fun :-D (I'm not going to do it though.)
"You should read..." Why about you read a little more than a Wikipedia page to write thousands of words? That page is filled with weasel words. Not sure why are absent the usual annotations like "citation needed", "who?" and so on that plague other pages for much less important vagueness.
You can add "citation needed" anywhere you think it needs it, go ahead. I think we've understood each other's perspectives well enough, and thanks for the discussion.
Just to be clear: I don't have a horse in this race. For me it's exactly the same if there was a Jesus or there wasn't. The point that we were discussing is that you can argue the case within reason. I can't see anything you have presented to be a rebuttal.
>The question is not how many scholars do or don't believe it, but what are the reasons
I don't quite agree with this. Neither of us are in a position to make a proper evaluation of the evidence, since we lack the relevant expertise. Trusting the overwhelming consensus of scholars in a given field is usually the sensible thing to do, unless you are yourself an expert in that field.
You are defending an authority fallacy in soft but unequivocal terms. My advice is to learn about History standards in general and then applying them to this particular case. A question: who do you think the experts in this field are?
The claimed advantage of this design is that it makes removing and replacing the cylinder easier and a user could reload by removing the spent cylinder and replacing it with a previously-loaded cylinder.
There are plenty of reasons why this seems unlikely in reality. It's faster than reloading a cylinder, but it's still not all that fast. On some models, at least, removing the cylinder requires hammering out the wedge from the frame and cylinder pin---something you don't want loose while firing. Dropping any of the parts would be a bad idea. But the major unfortunate problem with the theory is that there is no record of Colt manufacturing large numbers of spare cylinders. Nor, during the American Civil War, are there any records of the United States government ordering any large numbers of spare cylinders.
This isn't to claim that no one ever did it. That would be ridiculous; someone would certainly have thought about the idea anyway. But there's no evidence that anyone was ever trained to do it, or that large numbers of anyones ever had the materials necessary.
I've visited countless museums/castles in western, central and eastern europe, most of them if not all had some flails shown. no decorations on them, just varied length of spikes and size of the head ball. chains looked rigid enough to last many battles, probably much longer than bearer would survive.
somewhere I read that flail was very hard to block if used by skilled warrior - the chain would go around any blades, axes and shields and just hit the body. of course in unskilled hands, I can imagine it can easily harm/kill the bearer, compared to say a plain good old sword.
Finding few mentions in the literature or the examples you can examine being decorative rather than functional are better arguments (though not necessarily definitive, as you say).
The biggest point to the flail was to be a 'focused impact' weapon, and to have much more heft than a person could manage with a mace. The primary weapon used against people in plate armor was impact weapons like this - especially with sharp studs on them, because - believe it or not, armor actually worked. Swords couldn't cut through armor, and it was really hard to get around armor - nobody went after a knight by hoping to slide a blade through joints in the armor (as has been depicted in various films), because it's nearly impossible to do - nobody's going to stand still and just let you do it, and even if they did, it's surprisingly hard to control a sword like that (to illustrate this, try flipping a light switch with the far end of a broom handle - that's a still, unmoving target, and you might find it takes a rather surprising amount of manual control).
If you wanted to take out a dismounted knight, you went after one by punching a hole in his armor (or by hitting the armor with so much heft that it dents; either one works). Swords aren't an option, and until the late period crossbows/arbalests, very few arrows had the stopping power to punch through it (english longbows being a noted exception). The best bet was a spike - basically a large chisel on a stick. It needs to have a lot of momentum to have a hope of punching through - unfortunately this usually means it has to be extremely heavy. This usually results in a really unwieldy thing with the heft of a sledgehammer, that's so slow you can't fight well with it and are liable to be unable to dodge/block someone striking you with something much faster.
A moving weight on a chain solves the momentum problem by moving in a circle - it gives much more momentum than you could get in a single swing, since you can accelerate over a few rotations and continue to swing the weapon. It also is an inherently scary-looking thing, and has a powerful "crowd control" effect in a melee - the big point of a commander fielding something like this is to break up enemy cohesion/formations. A guy swinging a flail around repels people like oil and water. A few of these who bum rush a shield line (along with a general charge of their fellow fighters) are - more often than not, going to make a hole in the shield line not from actually hitting anybody, but from regular humans just getting the hell out of the way. Break up the enemy line, and they lose all of the strengths of being in formation. This is what "shock troops" are.
The flail is very similar to a number of asian designs (some of which are fairly mundane western-looking things, and others which are pretty exotic like the meteor-hammer/monkey's paw).
It's absolutely daft to dismiss a design like this, where not only do all of the parts of its shape serve a very direct, functional purpose, but also which has managed to "independently evolve" on multiple continents because it's just the only reasonable solution to dealing with armored shield-bearers. It's crazy.
It's a profoundly stupid kind of weapon to use in any kind of medieval mass battle, where quarters would be close and room to swing such a thing would be at a premium. There's a reason the Roman gladius and the seax were short little blades, designed for stabbing people in the groin underneath their shields.
With bizarre Asian weaponry, I can't help but be skeptical about whether it is real, or wildly over-inflated flights of whimsy designed to impress some foolish Englishman.
These were rare "shock troop" weapons used by a scant few guys in the center of your line to scare (or pummel) enemy troops out of formation. These scant few guys were shock troops - blackguards, dopplesoldners - specially selected guys of unusually large stature, outfitted with unusually good armor, paid unusually well, and taking a high risk. Showmanship was a big part of it - the guys we're talking about were the Sandor Cleganes of their time; gigantic guys specifically selected to look scary, but also to legitimately be dangerous.
Just like football players can fall back a few steps, so too would their allies - to give them enough room to swing something like this around and basically punch a hole in the enemy line - knock a few guys down, make a few trip over each other whilst trying to get out of the way - whatever. Once this was done, the flail would get dropped like a baseball bat (the shock trooper would switch to some sidearm like the gladius (or katzbalger, really) you mentioned, because now the fighting switches to close-quarters), and the shock trooper's allies (standing just a few paces behind him, just at a safe distance) would charge forward to make a wedge and try to divide the opposing line. Because they were at the ready and on their feet (as opposed to the enemies who just got knocked down/maimed), they had an advantage of maybe 30-60 seconds over them. Enough to get in there and cut the line.
This was one of many, many techniques used to break up close-quarters fighting and neutralize the advantages of the enemy formation. Formations were everything - if two forces were fighting on equal terms, whichever one could break the other's formation could win the battle - and not just against even odds, but also against overwhelming odds. One of the most famous examples of this was Ceasar's Battle of Alesia - by punching through the gallic lines, he divided their forces, and was able to isolate and panic one major group of them with a cavalry charge - because that group was cut off from the rest of them, and they seemed (locally) to be completely outnumbered, they panicked and ran, leaving all of their compatriots behind, letting the romans beat them piece by piece. Likewise, in another major historical incident - this was also basically how Arminius defeated the three roman legions in his famous rout - he caught them in the woods, on ground where they couldn't assume the testudo formation. He planned it.
The point is that outfitting a few soldiers with exotic "crowd control" equipment was a small price to pay to potentially win a battle, especially when the soldiers in question were fully functional as regular fighters by just switching to the sword at their belt.
Anyways, I've said my peace, so I won't be reading any further replies. Folks can get entire degrees studying this stuff, and this is pretty well established that these were a thing.
FYI, I'm downvoting because of this "LA LA LA I CAN'T HEAR YOU" business, not because of the scholarship.
Come to think of it, how is there not a whole class of medieval weapons that were focused on taking out the horse rather than the rider? The only one I've heard of is the caltrop.
Spears, pikes, halberds - the best way of countering cavalry was a thick hedge of pokey sticks, deep and massy enough to counter the shock of the charge.
A big part of the effectiveness of longbowmen was not through directly killing knights and men-at-arms with their arrows, but injuring and killing their horses out from underneath them - then wading in with mauls and axes to beat on the bogged down chivalry. A maul swung by a man trained to draw an English longbow would make a head, even in a helmet, look like a watermelon that Gallagher got into.
Other anti-cavalry methods were decidedly unsexy and low-tech. Form up at the top of a hill, or behind a swampy, wet muddy area. Prepare the battle site by digging potholes for a horse to step in and break a leg, scatter caltrops, sharpened stakes, logs and rocks to injure the horses and disrupt formations.
I actually tried. It's hard do take you seriously anymore...
The other extreme would be something like the falchion[2], with the weight concentrated near the end of the blade for chopping, like a scaled up meat cleaver or machete.
Note the LOTR clip where it was used as a left-hand weapon, essentially a shield. It doesn't need to do any actual damage. It's all about keeping your opponent at a distance and their eyes off of you. A lump of iron flailing around almost uncontrollably does exactly that.
I can easily picture how a 3' metal bar, spun as fast as a strong and practiced man could move it would be intimidating and deadly, shattering swords and shields, and chopping through any possible armor with ease.
>as a weapon of war, the flail is not a good design.
The fact that its not a good design does not mean that it didn't exist. The world is filled with things that actually exist, today, that are terribly designed. A careful study of history will likely turn up more things that are terribly designed then things that are well designed. Its amazing anyone would contend, "it couldn't have existed, because it was a bad design". Just what society did this author grow up in?
That the spiked ball and chain was not a particularly good weapon, I'll grant, and it represents a dead end. It just looks fierce, it always did.
But don't conflate that with "didn't exist".
And dead end? How dare you! You can always put on more chains. Until you end up with a cat-o-nine-balls.
For example, if the opponent is carrying a large shield or is lightly armored on the back, the flail could be used in a wrap around hit.
Maybe it already has been done.
Although in this case I'd probably go with the "it just was very rare" crowd. We've got all kinds of weird weaponry: three section staves, dueling shields, executioner swords, hunga mungas, mancatchers... People tried and still try a lot to kill other people, but in the end it comes down to the basics most often (like swords, spears and open office plans).
At least we'll always have enough evidence for all three squazillion variants of polearms.