You are being followed: The business of social media surveillance
littlesis.org
littlesis.org
It depends on a PHP application but that is easy to find on Github too.[1] I've been porting this PHP application to Powershell too, work in progress. Next step is moving to Elastic Search for data storage.
The blog I created 10 ago bashing homosexuals is now a problem.
I used racists slurs against someone on an forum 5 years ago which now show up as top results.
etc. etc. you get the point.
I will of course share all the necessary credentials with the target company.
But none of that protects you when some kid who made a copy of things and posts them again and again on some random forum site like one of the chan sites or some other home grown forum. Eventually it will be indexed again and you'll be back trying to whack it out of existence. Sorry.
Often you can't take back what you said, BUT you can change e.g a non archived profile image to associate comments with a fake account.
Related question: is it best to give a child a unique, or very generic name?
Currently I lean towards generic, as unique names or pseudonyms can be created on demand.
All of this intersects in interesting ways with "real name" policies IMHO
You the programmer get a request to target John K Smith you make a virus specifically for that person. Then the virus is released where infects anything it can and if it finds John K Smith it deletes or permanently encrypts the info.
"At its worst, social media monitoring could create classes of 'pre-criminals' apprehended before they commit crimes if police and prosecutors are able to argue that social media postings forecast intent. This is the predictive business model to which Geofeedia CEO Phil Harris aspires."
And I think it's a decent concern. If somebody tries to build a profile of you out of your social media presence, they're most likely getting a pretty inaccurate (or biased) picture of you, which is especially concerning if they aren't aware of the limitations of these profiles - and judging by the history of things like polygraphs, this is likely the case. This potentially has consequences for your employment/background checks, or any time your character is called into question, in general.
Shouldn't the same principle apply to mentioned companies and law enforcement agencies as well then?
That being said, I think you're really misusing the "innocent until proven guilty" idea. If a complete stranger appeared on your doorstep wielding a steak knife and offered to help you prepare dinner in exchange for him staying the night on your couch, would you assume he was innocent, let him in, and then not keep a watchful eye on him? Most people would not, and this suggests that, all else being equal, most people would prefer to act in ways that don't put them at risk.
So I disagree that we should automatically assume that the intelligence community are all innocent. Nor do I think we should assume any of them are guilty with evidence. But I absolutely believe it's ok to watch them with scrutiny until we understand the implications of this data being used in investigations. Keeping a watchful eye on governments and companies encourages accountability. That's a good thing.
For fairness, here's a blog post by Brightplanet, one of the subjects of the OP, called "What is OSINT and how can your organization use it? [0]
Many of the same issues that came up in discussion of the recent OKCupid study [1] apply to this piece. I liked what AnhonyMuse wrote in reply to my comment: "people want to create a binary distinction between 'public' (meaning public domain, can be used for anything by anyone) and 'private' (meaning something known solely to a single individual), with no intermediary steps between them."
This point applies especially to people's feelings on "social media surveillance." To those most concerned about it, an easy argument exists: if you didn't want to be surveilled, why did you post it "publicly" on the Internet? The problem with this argument is that, as AnthonyMuse pointed out, people have different definitions, and therefore expectations, of what is public.
Personally, I think that "open source intelligence" or "social media surveillance," or whatever you want to call it, needs to become as mainstream as Google. Its power is only "creepy" or corruptible so long as only a few entities can wield it. Surveillance in the hands of a few is dangerous; surveillance in the hands of many is powerful. When everyone has the power to spy on everybody else, then everyone must correctly calibrate their "expectations" for what is public and what is not. If you know that some percentage of your friends on social media are using "surveillance" tools, then you'll be more careful about what you post, because you will understand the true meaning of "public." Whereas if all the surveillance continues to happen in secret, you will continue to post recklessly, blissfully unaware of just how "public" your posts are.
We need to democratize open source intelligence in order to balance the power between those who currently hold it and those who don't. Why should the NSA have all the fun?
Will the "next Google" be a company that indexes the "deep web" [2] and provides a search engine for it?
[0] https://brightplanet.com/2013/04/what-is-osint-and-how-can-y...
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11705677
[2] Deep web meaning pages behind paywalls or requiring registration. Not Tor.
P.S. I feel the same way about propaganda. Why should government agencies be the only ones with the power to propagandize their message? Everyone should have access to top-of-the-line shilling software!
But most every day people don't have the resources to pay for marketing & servers to run massive operations.
For precisely this reason they become useless when open-sourced.
And on the other hand it's not like they're great works of art. They're weekend hacks driving a rest API or phantomjs. Most of the "art" is threading or concurrency and getting it all to go over a 4K line "free proxy" list without falling over too badly.
Want 10k Twitter accounts? It's not magic. It's just some dumb scripts and a bit of patience.
You don't need massive server power (a $5 droplet will do fine) but you do have to have a bunch of time to waste.
But privacy that is conditional and breachable by only few is very very bad.
This may help reduce the asymmetry of power, but is it not a case of "throwing the baby out with the bath water"? We lose the exact freedom we are trying to protect - the freedom to act so-called "recklessly" or "inappropriately" in respect to popular opinion.
Privacy is only necessary now because when you lose it, when someone else holds such a detailed profile of your behavior, there's a deep power imbalance. If you received a similarly detailed profile on everyone who was privy to yours, it wouldn't be so bad - and that's exactly what GP proposed.
I think there's something deeply immoral about asking someone to ignore, for your sake, some physical phenomenon that's occurring as much in their universe as yours.
1. It's not information that wants to be free, but access to published information. Where the roots of the word "publish" in "public" are germane. In addition to published information, information on public institutions such as governments, government agencies, bureaucracies, major social actors, the wealthy (who've gained strongly through socially-mediated systems), and those guilty of crimes against society.
2. Information doesn't balance power imbalances, it magnifies them. Though the empowered and disempowered have different vulnerabilities and strengths. Hence information can work against the empowered and disempowered in different ways.
Absent a handle or pivot point for power, information yields none. You simply have understanding of a process you cannot manipulate.
Except it would be because some entities posess much better capabilities to leverage that data.
valor deletus
The US government after WWII was wondering how to avoid a situation in their own country that lead up to the holocaust. They studied Sigmund Freud to learn how to "manipulate" the crowds into "being happy" or create the illusion of happiness with distraction or consumerism. Freud's uncle, (Hugo Bernaise[1]) enjoyed massive influence among political circles and and gave them and corporations advise[2] on manipulating and controlling the masses.
There is an excellent BBC mini series (also available on youtube) called "The century of the self" ... The episode that talks specifically about Freud and Bernaise is called "Engineering Consent".
The documentary may seem slightly dated but in light of recent geopolitical developments and our discussion about government and corporate surveillance it's worth every minute!
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edward_Bernays
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Engineering_of_Consent
You can turn off JS, use tor/vpn, adblock, etc, but we've seen time and time again that there are ways around each one of those strategies. I'm not saying this is ethical or correct, but it is happening and you can't really stop it.
I think its ethical and don't mind. If you post something with a username attached, its traceable and you should understand that. 99.9% of collection is anonymized and used to create better products, offer free* services, improve the internet, etc.
[citation needed]