Not the same, but there was an article about file system fuzzing recently: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11469535

The presentation is focused on how the fuzzing technique works rather than individual file system performance, but the "time to first bug" is quite telling. Copied here:

    ext4 (2h)
    XFS (1h45)
    GFS2 (8m)
    NTFS (4m)
    NILFS2 (1m)
    HFS (30s)
    HFS+ (25s)
    ReiserFS (25s)
    OCFS2 (15s)
    F2FS (10s)
    BTRFS (5s)

I've had miscellaneous failures with the bottom three, but XFS and ext4 have been rock solid. Unfortunately ZFS and CephFS were not included.

Would love to see a Jepsen-style analysis of the various file systems too.