Run your own mailserver, in your home or a semi-trusted local colo. Full disk encryption, fully encrypted offsite backups. Cabinet door reed switch triggers immediate power-down in the absence of a cryptographically signed override.
Run your own mailserver, in your home or a semi-trusted local colo. Full disk encryption, fully encrypted offsite backups. Cabinet door reed switch triggers immediate power-down in the absence of a cryptographically signed override.
What we've really got is a protocols/software/UI problem. The end-to-end nature of the Internet came out of engineering sense, which was necessary to bootstrap it but not necessary for its continued functioning (hence it's slide back toward centralization eg DPI gear). What we need are better protocols that explicitly protect the end-to-end principle.
One should be able to have an untrusted cloud "mail server" that knows only what it needs to, passing messages to a slightly more trusted home server (your half-hardened hardware is really only protected by it's unique nature, so not scalable). A message only needs to be fully unlocked when it is being read. And the system needs to work this way out of the box with a minimum of configuring, because sysadmin work is an annoyance when you're just trying to get something done.
It is, but it doesn't have to be. Someone could make a <$100 device which has a power backup for running through power outages and a backup network connection via the cellular network, which should provide high enough uptime for all practical purposes. Messages between mail servers are encrypted most of the time, more and more so every year [1]. This is a technical solution for a legal problem, though.
I'm not sure if I understand the system you are proposing, but email protocols seem secure enough now as they are now, it's just the third party principle that doesn't align with the obvious expectations of privacy in mail [2]. To me, it's pretty clear that my email account is like a PO box. Just because my email is held by a third party doesn't make it any less private than being delivered to my home, just as mail arriving at a "third-party" PO box isn't all that different from my mailbox.
1. https://www.google.com/transparencyreport/saferemail/ 2. http://techcrunch.com/2014/04/30/google-will-also-stop-scann...
Protocols "seem" secure enough, because you don't seem to be focused on the technicals (which is fine, as per what I just said. Just don't nay-say). For example, even if messages are encrypted between servers, the graph of who is talking to who is still revealed to a passive adversary, and this problem only gets worse with individually-run servers.