Patents
ignorethecode.net
ignorethecode.net
It is common to argue that intellectual property in the form of copyright and patent is necessary for the innovation and creation of ideas and inventions such as machines, drugs, computer software, books, music, literature and movies. In fact intellectual property is a government grant of a costly and dangerous private monopoly over ideas. We show through theory and example that intellectual monopoly is not necessary for innovation and as a practical matter is damaging to growth, prosperity and liberty. -- David K. Levine and Michele Boldrin, Against Intellectual Monopoly
It will cost you exactly nothing to read the electronic version of the book, so read it!
P.S. Yes, I been making the same book recommendation for the last several threads about IP, but it doesn't seem to have an impact on the quality of discussion.
Patents exist to encourage and reward innovation and invention, by granting 20-year monopolies on new ideas.
Software does not need additional motivation for innovation because there is and was tremendous innovation and invention, and would be without patents.
20-year patents on software concepts reduce the rate of innovation in software.
I can't work out whether the third paragraph is intended to follow from the second (non sequitur), or stand by itself (unsupported claim). But it's not a good argument either way.
"In granting a 20-year monopoly, patents can have good and bad effects; they can encourage invention by appealing to inventors who desire a limited-time monopoly, but they can discourage invention by scaring away inventors who don't want to run afoul of patents already held by others. In the field of software, which already had a high rate of invention without the encouragement of patents, the benefits of patents are marginal and are likely outweighed by their drawbacks."
Of course, the challenge is to quantify the argument and back it up with facts.
You see well known problems discussed, such as prior art being buried in compiled code and the lack of awareness in general of the prior art the examiners have (usually they just do searches on the patent archive).
However, I haven't seen as much discussion of the problem that software patents are just not needed to spur innovation in the software arena in the first place, since rapid innovation would occur anyway. (Not to mention granting a 20-year monopoly in regular years is like granting a 100-year monopoly in software years.)
Counterarguments?
Whenever I try and reason about patents, I think of the development of the steam engine. Patents seem to have been developed for that time period and that kind of invention. Anyone can look at a steam engine and understand how all of the parts work. When someone came up with a clever way of solving a problem, making a better steam engine, anyone could have easily seen what they did and made their own version. Patents protected the inventor and allowed him to recoup his R&D expenses. So when you look at the evolution of the steam engine you see places where people licensed patents from previous inventors and places where they came up with different (often less efficient) solutions to previously solved problems because the previous solution was patented. I think that this is an example of the patent system working well. Steam engines evolved rapidly and inventors were able to continue inventing because they could make money off of their ideas.
The question now is how appropriate are patents in software, a field that is very very different from the mechanical nuts and bolts field that they were created for. I don't know the answer to that question, but it is shitty for small players to be in constant fear of the big guys.
edit, found it! http://mises.org/daily/3280
edit: it's an excerpt from the book kiba is talking about above.
The real question is whether patents are really appropriate at all, not whether it is just inappropriate for one field or another.
It's hard to see how to put one-click shopping in a box.