Miami money-laundering case may define whether Bitcoin is really money
miamiherald.com
miamiherald.com
The SEC and the CFTC have agreed that Bitcoin will be treated as a commodity for regulatory purposes, so the CFTC regulates it.
[1] https://ia800904.us.archive.org/35/items/gov.uscourts.txed.1...
But stick to this 2012 crypto-anarcho argument that "its not US dollars so therefore you have no jurisdiction"
silly
Initially launched as btclending.com it was 1%/day, invite/referral only and payouts were every 3 days. Effectively it was 7%/week, compound into something like 3300% APR.
That being said as the website ui and backend transitioned from btclending.com to "First Pirate Savings & Trust" and ultimately btcst.com (Bitcoin Savings & Trust) more people started "getting in on the action" rules were changed, payouts went to once per week, blah blah... obviously a ponzi doesn't scale well. In the end minimum balances were required to stay in the "7%/week bracket" where balances <1000BTC were only earning 5.5%/week.
If anyone that sets off your ponzi red flag detectors - well done.
I can say that there were a handful of early GPU miners with truckloads of sub 5 dollar bitcoins and no where to invest them. GPU Miners who built mining rigs that literally ROI'd in days or weeks, not months. Did some people get burned? Obviously. Did others milk free interest? Most likely.
Where I think Trendon and many others have ultimately failed - and this especially goes for Espinoza and his failed "bitcoin isn't money" argument - NOT PRACTICING KYC.
There's a lot of smart people out there that know to walk from the transaction when the counterparty mentions tor/fraud/crime/buying stolen credit cards. Espinoza obviously didn't think facilitating the purchase of stolen credit cards was a problem (or didn't care)
I'm not sure this specific article mentions it or not but the agents doing the undercover buy from localbitcoins told the seller Espinoza it was for fake credit cards. Huge Red flag for the bitcoin seller.
In general though, I would agree with OP that bitcoin is some type of money already defined by precedent and Espinoza is getting reamed for no MSB license and not practicing KYC.
For the case that is the subject of the article, the relevant question is "Is someone who exchanges bitcoins for US dollars a 'money services business' as defined by chapter 560 of the Florida statutes?"
Read a few definitions from the statute and you'll likely be able to answer the question: http://www.leg.state.fl.us/Statutes/index.cfm?App_mode=Displ...
Based on my (non-lawyerly) reading, I would say bitcoin is not a currency, and thus a bitcoin dealer is not a foreign currency dealer, but it is almost certainly a "payment instrument" which means selling bitcoins makes you a seller of payment instruments, and a seller of payment instruments is a "money services business".
Interestingly, you get different results depending on what laws you're looking at. For instance I reach the opposite conclusion when reading the Illinois statutes, and think you can probably sell bitcoins there legally. (http://www.ilga.gov/legislation/ilcs/ilcs3.asp?ActID=1201&) Though this guy sold them even though the undercover cops told him they were going to use it to buy stolen credit card numbers. That's just dumb, and I would guess prosecutors can find something to charge you with if you do that in almost any state. (And it's definitely a violation of US Federal anti-money laundering law if you don't file a SAR)
That episode in particular was an excellent example of balancing technical accuracy and artistic licence (e.g. the creator's alias is "Mr. Bitcoin" instead of Satoshi Nakamoto).
A lot of shows that do their research seem to feel a need to show it off by having nerds spouting word salad, which while completely accurate, is not something anyone would actually say.