The most enlightening thing about this debate is the idea that we don't care about peoples basic standards of living and are happy to pretend there is no problem.
PS: Although the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development in January 2012 annual point-in-time count found that 633,782 people across the United States were homeless, other counts vary widely. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_the_United_Sta...
Note: Many people end up homeless temporarily which makes counting complex.
A study just done about a year ago in the City I live in, housed a fairly large number of the non-temporary homeless people (between 20 and 50 I want to say, the numbers escape me) in an apartment complex that provided basic social services and access to health care. They found that in actuality, this helped solve many of the long term problems (even if it did not solve all the problems for all the people), as these people now had access to health care, _AND_ it saved money, because these people were no longer ending up in the emergency room or the local jail (and a few other cost saving measures as well)
I'm pretty sure you don't know what you're talking about.
I'm 100% sure I don't know what I'm talking about! That's why I couched my opinion in all the weasel words like "probably" and "likely".
What makes you think most land is owned through birthright? Any stats to back that up? I would assume most land was purchased.
And if you levy a big tax on property, be prepared for the value of that property to drop dramatically. Money flows freely from one asset to another. If land becomes unattractive, those dollars will just go elsewhere.
Purchased from whom? I would imagine a lot of land in the most desirable locations (cities etc) are owned by private individuals or family trusts/companies, so they have been/will be inherited (even if the owners change in between). And if it's owned by a corporation, I guess the same logic could apply.
> And if you levy a big tax on property, be prepared for the value of that property to drop dramatically. Money flows freely from one asset to another. If land becomes unattractive, those dollars will just go elsewhere.
Yeah, that's kind of the point. Land used for investment is the purest form of unproductive rent-seeking.
> Poverty is an issue long solved in the USA.
When? How?EDIT: While I disagree with the parent poster, primarily because I've seen plenty of homeless, underemployed, malnourished individuals in my travels around the US my entire life, and no significant decline in the past several years, my questions were not meant entirely sarcastically.
If poverty is solved, explain how or by what measure you consider it to be solved.
My viewpoint:
From a purely technical standpoint it could be considered solveable. We have sufficient housing, clothing, food for literally everyone in this country, and more. The issue becomes one of distribution. But just having the resources doesn't mean that the problem itself is solved.
That is enough money in most places to rent a basic apartment and buy plenty of food to eat. Plenty of people in that bracket also have cable TV and a car and a smart phone. It's not easy and it's not all that much fun, but you're not going to starve or freeze to death and the Wheel of Fortune you watch every night is the same Wheel of Fortune that Bill Gates watches.
That's the definition of "solved" that's in play here.
These people need to move, which is a non-trivial cost. There's no guarantee they'll get a job when they go to, say, Atlanta. And they'll be paying more in rent or living in even worse living conditions (crammed into small apartments with more people). They'd be giving up their connections to family and friends and a community that they've been a part of.
The problem of poverty will only be solved when no one is in poverty for any reason but choice. Calling it solved because technically there may be enough minimum wage jobs for everyone is the same as saying hunger is solved because technically there's enough food for everyone.
It can be hard to see because the problem is so unevenly distributed through the social fabric, but this is just objectively not true.
That's also just objectively not true, but when we're talking about the population as a whole, then it's an OK proxy for the complete truth.
I would prefer to be a homeless in USA than lower middle class in India.
When those are consequences of anything but rational, healthy, deliberate choice [0], or very temporary circumstances, then poverty is not solved.
[0] Which pretty much means religious/cultural reasons. The rationality of those choices are still debatable, but they aren't predicated on mental or physical illness.
On the other hand, some people obviously don't have able bodies or any support network to speak of. I think you both know that, too.
So, why he disconnect?
I'm not so sure. I know people who are able bodied, college degree educated, and some months can barely afford groceries after all non-discretionary spending is accounted for.
(It's not the worst of what people experience, and I would not personally call poverty solved.)
And his point still stands, it's an issue in the US that has yet to be solved.
(Of course, that's referring to the United States)
"Your opinion is worthless" isn't a useful debating tactic when you're talking to people with as much political power as you yourself have.