Arguments from "but this is how it always have been" have a tendency to break down when significant societal/technological changes happen.
Arguments from "but this is how it always have been" have a tendency to break down when significant societal/technological changes happen.
1) jobs that mostly create economic value (doctors, farmers, programmers): the percentage of these jobs is already small and keeps decreasing with technology.
2) jobs that mostly transfer economic value (marketers, lawyers): these jobs keep increasing. (Note: I'm not saying marketing and law doesn't create value but more marketers and lawyers mostly means more value transfers rather than more value)
3) jobs that arbitrage time and money (executive assistant, cleaning person): I call these arbitrage because the dollar value of time varies between individuals varies and so they trade time and both win economically. These jobs likely grow with inequality.
In a future where wealth is concentrated and more jobs are automated, job types 2 and 3 most likely grow, not shrink. That's what happened because of past technological progress and I don't see a reason to think it will happen any differently this time. In fact, I expect this to happen even more this time.
I'm not saying this is a great outcome. In fact, I think this is an argument for basic income. But I don't think jobs are going to disappear anytime soon.
The thing is, contrary to other eras, job types (3) (and some (2)) will be also be able to be performed by "robots"/software/technology.
Edit: And once we get there, I'm sure there will be more things I want done for me if I have money to hire someone.
You just picked 2 convenient examples (handling a baby, doing work around the house) were it would need full "human-like" robots with AI.
But I wasn't discussing these: there are tons of type (2) jobs that can be nevertheless automated, or will be very soon.
I don't see the problem of lost jobs due to automation being solved by everybody becoming a babysitter or buttler.
I really don't follow why job types 2 and 3 would grow instead of shrink; shouldn't job types 1 and 2 be the ones to increase with technological advances?
Technological advancements meant massive increases in output per farmer but farming itself does not require specialized skills, so the increased productivity lead to the drop in the farmer population. Contrast this with activities like programming and medicine which cannot be automated wholesale -- programming and medicine do require specialized skills.
For instance, we'll need more programmers in future than we have now since someone has to program/maintain code written for self-driving cars (for the rest of the population), precision farming (for farmers), telemedicine (for doctors) etc, and with efforts like Learnable Programming [1], more people will pick up programming as a career, so the ranks of people that identify with the programming profession would swell not decrease.
I believe the same increased productivity would eventually happen to the field of medicine -- if computers become really good at the basic stuff -- physical examinations that can produce an initial diagnosis that is fairly accurate, would-be doctors will spend a shorter time in training since they have less material to master. I think this will eventually lead to more people qualifying to become doctors.
So the point I'm making is that including farmers along with doctors and programmers as examples of job type 1 needs some rethinking.
I might amend your description of 2) to be "Jobs that mostly transfer economic value and provide competitive advantage". The increase of these jobs is driven by arms race style competition among capital owners.
I'm curious if you have any ideas of ways to combat the constant increase of type 2) jobs as I see them as a drain on our economic output.
I my hope is that BI means that the low intrinsic value of type 2) and some type 3) jobs means that this shift will be slowed or possibly even reversed.
Not sure how to fix 2.
I also hope BI would reduce 2 and 3. It seems like it would. I certainly wouldn't work those jobs if didn't need money.