/s
No really, what gives people the impression that STEM majors can't think independently or well?
/s
No really, what gives people the impression that STEM majors can't think independently or well?
I have met very few people who look at either situation and see the breadth of information that exists and how valuable it can be to analyze and model.
Someone who has been working for years under the engineering culture and code review regime on an elite Google distributed systems team is probably going to write better code (at least in that domain) then someone who did a couple of side projects after reading the Rails tutorial.
I wonder if this attitude is more prevalent in the US, where people routinely say "you can do anything with a law degree", viewing law as a generalist degree, while viewing engineering or math as a narrow, task-specific degree with no real use outside those subjects…
Although I double majored in English Literature and Math, I did notice the extent to which I would have been required to study humanities as a math major in college (UCSD) without the double major in lit. My general education requirements included a two year undergraduate survey course on world history, a required upper division sequence in a humanities field focusing on a specific region (such as a one year upper division sequence on European or Asian history), two years or proven competence in a foreign language, a year of arts (fine arts, art history, theater), and a minor in a humanities field.
That may be a bit heavier than usual, but in general, math and science majors are required to take a great deal of humanities. The humanities majors, by contrast, had to take two courses in "math" which could be fulfilled with symbolic logic in the philosophy dept and stats for the social sciences (no calculus or even a modicum of advanced math required). The science could be fulfilled through "physics for humanities majors" and bio classes not intended for science track students. Again, that may be a bit light, but it's pretty consistent in US universities - humanities majors get away with minimal math and science, whereas science, engineering, and math majors must take substantial humanities coursework.
One more thing - although the humanities were rigorous, the partiers were pretty much all humanities or social science majors. At least at UCSD, it was nearly impossible to survive in engineering or science as a "partier". Not to say these students were never at the parties, but they spent a lot more time in labs and the library, it was pretty clear. Those and the pre-meds. The humanities majors who got good grades were serious students, sure, but it's pretty clear to me that they didn't have to work anywhere near as hard for good grades (this was also my personal experience in upper division lit classes vs upper division math classes).
This is why I think the most well-rounded students tend to be the STEM students. Not all STEM students are well rounded, many resent and minimize their humanities coursework, but the well-roundedness tends to be more deeply built into the curriculum for STEM than for humanities.
That seems like a good statement that accords with my experience at school.
I also have a peculiar resentment towards the humanities requirements: I had to take extra humanities requirements, on top of basically everything you already mentioned, for the "honors college" that was giving me the scholarship by which I avoided Student Loan Hell, so pretty much every semester when course selection came up, I had to make some sinister choices between fulfilling my scholarship requirements and taking sufficient coursework in math, CS, and the hard sciences to give me a good base of knowledge for the future.
The result is that I basically squeaked by in hard math (stopped after multivariable calculus and linear algebra) and CS, didn't take enough hard science (I really should have taken a physics course), and was under-prepared and even under-advised for the kind of research I wanted to do in graduate school. Graduate school notified me of this by forcing me to fight to have my degree considered a four-year Comp Sci degree at all.
In defense of the Technion, I really should have taken more rigorous coursework in undergrad: physics, better vector calculus, real analysis, category theory, a proper type-theory course. In my defense, my undergrad institution didn't even offer those latter two subjects, and my scholarship conditions simply did not have a track available for hard-science students.
The institution's idea of an "honors" or "honorable" education, deserving of financial support, was a humanities education finished inside of four years. They provided no coursework options for taking a scholarship-supported education in the hard sciences, and also would not give you additional years of scholarship so you could take their honors humanities education and your own rigorous science-and-math degree on top.
Basically, we pay people not to take science courses.
On a related note, what you've described in terms of graduate preparation is also a serious problem for domestic (US) students. I think there is merit to the more generalized approach to undergraduate education in the US, but we specialize very late in the US compared to other educational systems.
This becomes a problem when combined with the high attrition rates in PhD programs. When I enrolled in a PhD program at Berkeley, I noticed that the coursework seemed like review for many of my fellow students who had degrees from overseas. Some would chalk this up to superior mathematics education outside the US, but I do think that the late specialization plays a big role here as well. While I was taking those classes in literature, theater, arts, history, and so forth, my graduate classmates were specializing in mathematical optimization and stochastic processes much earlier, and in much greater depth.
I don't think that this would be an issue if attrition rates weren't so high, but PhD programs in STEM fields typically have attrition rates between 35%-50%. If you aren't ready to hit the ground running, odds are very good you won't survive the first two years. This isn't an issue in graduate programs in medicine and law in the US, which don't expect undergraduate specialization (and, at the elite level, have vanishingly low attrition rates anyway, typically below one half of one percent). Nobody is expected to study law prior to law school or medicine prior to medical school, and the overwhelming majority of students who start elite programs in these fields do finish (again, 99.5% or more typically do).
Unfortunately, the result is what the RAND institute already identified - top US students behave rationally by avoiding PhD programs in the sciences in favor of professional degrees in law, medicine, dentistry, etc. This is only one factor, but I do think the situation you faced - less specialization at the undergraduate level - also plays a role here.
That's exactly what a lot of my peers did. It's what I should have done, if not for the money.
>Unfortunately, the result is what the RAND institute already identified - top US students behave rationally by avoiding PhD programs in the sciences in favor of professional degrees in law, medicine, dentistry, etc. This is only one factor, but I do think the situation you faced - less specialization at the undergraduate level - also plays a role here.
I think the financial factor at the undergraduate level is just as strong. If it takes five years, or an inferior curriculum, to finish a degree in the sciences, and students have to pay large sums for each semester (and often face "bonus charges" from loss of financial aid after finishing four years without having completed a degree program), then as it occurred to me when summing up: we are paying people not to study science, and penalizing them when they try anyway.
The reason this drives me batty is that my elected officials (and silicon valley execs) constantly talk about a terrible "shortage" of STEM students, but our universities really do an amazing job driving people away from these fields, and it's not just the rigor of these topics, it's structural.
I hadn't thought of it this way before, but yeah, our undergraduate general ed requirements, while worthy in terms of getting a well-rounded education, probably do increase the attrition rates from science programs (and, because they reduce the amount of undergraduate specialization in math and science, may also increase the attrition rates from graduate STEM programs). Damn. Quite an accomplishment for universities in a nation that constantly frets about a "shortage" of students going into STEM.
In my day, you only had to take one Honors Gen-Ed, a high SAT Writing score exempted me from the Honors English requirement, and you could fill those horrid Any Honors Course requirements by just getting a certain number of professors from in-major courses, or an undergrad research supervisor (only once in your career, though) to write you a letter declaring that you were taking an Honors Colloquium.
(Mind, the idea of writing classes for everyone isn't actually that bad. UMass has a Junior-Year Writing requirement that every department has to fill with a course customized to their degree material. We Comp Sci kids had a writing course that taught us how to compose things like tech-marketing presentations, technical research papers, start-up pitches, and game designs. It was a great idea at core to give us a communications course specialized to our prospective line of work, even if they didn't teach LaTeX or anything that in-depth.
The objectionable thing is to have two writing courses, one of which is explicitly a gen-ed, and which actively penalizes students who try to eat into their coursework requirements with exam scores.)
Dear Lord, it's like they actually dislike the idea of depth. The very least they could do is ditch the stupid Gen-Ed stamp and just require a number of courses outside your own department or college. That would at least let Comp Sci students fill requirements in with physics or intro to analytic philosophy or something.
Or they could encourage breadth-with-depth by declaring that any student who double-majors can receive honors and scholarships without all the stupid stamps.
Oh, and now they charge a fee to be in the honors college, which is of course how you qualify for merit scholarships.
That's it, I'm writing them a letter. I hated this stuff when I was an undergrad, and it turns out that was entirely justified. Five years later, time to tell them.
>I hadn't thought of it this way before, but yeah, our undergraduate general ed requirements, while worthy in terms of getting a well-rounded education, probably do increase the attrition rates from science programs (and, because they reduce the amount of undergraduate specialization in math and science, may also increase the attrition rates from graduate STEM programs). Damn. Quite an accomplishment for universities in a nation that constantly frets about a "shortage" of students going into STEM.
Yeah. Damn.
honestly the biggest problems I've seen from my peers(college aged and new grads) are superiority complexes and not realizing when they are out of the bounds of their knowledge base.
The VP is also less powerful than a supreme court justice.
The VP is also less powerful than the house majority leader.
Things are less clear with governors, but I think the argument can be made that the VP is less powerful than the governors of California, Texas, Florida, New York, etc. Do you know those?
Also, remember what Feynman said his dad taught him about knowing the names of birds. Memorizing names gives a false sense of knowledge.
At least that's how it seems whenever this comes up.