If the company is hoarding cash, distributing dividends usually increases the stock price, since cash value is not included in the stock price. This is actually very important to understand, cash DOES NOT change a company's valuation (there are some exceptions and edge cases).
And corporate cash is usually invested in low-risk, liquid securities, which return far less than the average cost of capital for the company.
In other words, shareholders will be happier with the cash in their hands than in the company's bank account.
How much money do you need to buy this company?
The answer is zero.
You borrow 1B.
Buy the company.
Use the cash to pay back the debt.
Cash has no influence (with exceptions and edge cases) on a company's enterprise value.
Your broken logic could be applied to literally anything.
> Imagine company A, which has no significant cash, only a $1B tire manufacturing business.
> How much money do you need to buy this company?
> The answer is zero.
> You borrow 1B.
> Buy the company.
> Sell the time manufacturing business to pay back the debt.
> Manufacturing capacity has no influence (with exceptions and edge cases) on a company's enterprise value.
Or how about this?
> Imagine a used Honda Civic, which is a car that costs $10k.
> How much money do you need to buy this car?
> The answer is zero.
> You borrow $10k.
> Buy the car.
> Sell the car in parts on eBay to pay back the debt.
> Car parts have no influence (with exceptions and edge cases) on a car's value.
The fact that you can take out a loan to buy something, and turn around and liquidate the parts of that thing to pay back the loan does not mean the thing has no value.
Buying a Honda Civic is buying an asset which has intrinsic value, and can be used to generate value beyond the $ price.
Buying cash gives you no additional value.
So trust me, the amount of cash does not change Enterprise Value.
If you don't believe me, read any valuation materials, such as Damodaran's.
If you want to argue that there is no value in taking over a company for its cash, sure. If you want to argue that the market sees no value in cash, no.
Now, let us say the business issues a special Dividend of $10B. Can we all agree that a rational investor, on the ex-date, would now only spend $1B on this company, instead of $11B?
Maybe what you are suggesting is that a company with no history of issuing dividends, that starts to issue dividends, will see an increase in the stock price?
Exactly!
What might be confusing is that one dollar of cash at a company doesn't neatly translate into one dollar of value in the stock price. At a poorly run company with a history of bad acquisitions $1 of cash might be worth 50 cents because investors think that the company will waste the money rather than give it back as dividends. But a growing company might borrow money and have the stock price go up, if investors think it will be invested well.
Under certain conditions, the same is valid for debt. Capital structure of a company (under certain conditions) has no impact on the value of the company.
This is the Modigliani-Miller theorem, it got Modigliani (but sadly, not Miller) a nobel prize.
Fine print: there are a bunch of conditions in the case of debt, due to tax, and so on.
That's wrong. As you say later, the Enterprise Value (= Market Cap - Cash + Debt) doesn't change when the company accumulates cash. But the Market Cap increases. Otherwise, how do you balance the equation to keep the Enterprise Value unchanged?
Go look at a MSFT, PG or any other stocks that pay regular dividends on Google Finance. You'll see their stock is obviously not influenced by the value of the dividend payment at all. It's impossible to tell when dividends are distributed by looking at the stock price change alone.
If what I was saying was false, then the ex-date of the dividend should always close at a lower price than the previous day. However, it's a coin flip as to whether or not the ex date stock price closes above or below the previous day. This suggests that regular dividends are factored into the price of a stock.
You're trying to claim that the ex-date of the stock should close at $previous_close - $dividend every time. But that doesn't happen. When reality and theory disagree, trust reality.
For most companies the dividend distribution is less than average daily variance of stock prices. Which is why your strategy won't necessarily yield great results. A 3% yield distributed four times a year is only 0.75% of the stock value.
The SEC also has special rules for extremely large dividends so that the ex-date is after the distribution date.
Yes - it's true that if you are just looking at a stock chart, it might be hard to eyeball the date of the dividend if there is a lot of volatility, but, presuming that volatility is evenly distributed over various stocks dividend dates, there is no way to avoid having the stock drop down by the value of the dividend. I guarantee you there is a pretty large number of investment bankers who have all sorts of models that arbitrage that kind of variance, pretty much eliminating any gap, should it exist for more than a few seconds after opening.
I don't understand how the ex-date could occur after the distribution date. The whole idea behind the ex-date, is that is the date on which the dividend belongs to the seller, not the buyer. I.E. If I buy the stock on (or after) the ex-date, I do not get the dividend, it belongs to the seller. Depending on the exchange, it's usually two business days prior to the date of record set by the board of directors. (At least on the SGX, the exchange I'm familiar with). So how could you place the ex-date after the distribution date? What would the date of record be in that case?
Here is my favorite resource on this topic - http://www.spdrs.com.sg/education/files/SPDRU%20Dividend%20D...
library(quantmod)
getSymbols(c("MSFT","PG","SPY"))
msft.ex=index(quantmod::getDividends("MSFT")["2007::"])
pg.ex=index(quantmod::getDividends("PG")["2007::"])
msft.rets=as.data.frame(merge(dailyReturn(MSFT$MSFT.Close)[msft.ex],dailyReturn(SPY$SPY.Close)[msft.ex]))
colnames(msft.rets)=c("MSFT","SPY")
msft.fit=lm(MSFT~SPY,msft.rets)
summary(msft.fit)
confint(msft.fit)
pg.rets=as.data.frame(merge(dailyReturn(PG$PG.Close)[pg.ex],dailyReturn(SPY$SPY.Close)[pg.ex]))
colnames(pg.rets)=c("PG","SPY")
pg.fit=lm(PG~SPY,pg.rets)
summary(pg.fit)
confint(pg.fit)
par(mfrow=c(1,2))
plot(msft.rets$SPY,msft.rets$MSFT,xlim=c(-0.08,0.08),ylim=c(-0.08,0.08))
abline(msft.fit,col="red")
grid()
plot(pg.rets$SPY,pg.rets$PG,xlim=c(-0.08,0.08),ylim=c(-0.08,0.08))
abline(pg.fit,col="red")
grid()Maybe this helps: http://r4ds.had.co.nz But note it's a blind recommendation, I didn't know about this particular book before.
I found a long list of books here: http://blog.revolutionanalytics.com/2015/11/r-recommended-re...
A simple thought experiment should make it clear why that is - Let's say a $100 stock has a $2 dividend, if the stock didn't drop by the amount of the dividend on the ex-dividend date, then I could simply purchase the stock, be the owner of record on the ex-dividend date, receive the dividend, and then just sell the stock immediately. I get a 2% return for holding the stock for a week or less. Clearly that doesn't happen.