How much money do you need to buy this company?
The answer is zero.
You borrow 1B.
Buy the company.
Use the cash to pay back the debt.
Cash has no influence (with exceptions and edge cases) on a company's enterprise value.
Your broken logic could be applied to literally anything.
> Imagine company A, which has no significant cash, only a $1B tire manufacturing business.
> How much money do you need to buy this company?
> The answer is zero.
> You borrow 1B.
> Buy the company.
> Sell the time manufacturing business to pay back the debt.
> Manufacturing capacity has no influence (with exceptions and edge cases) on a company's enterprise value.
Or how about this?
> Imagine a used Honda Civic, which is a car that costs $10k.
> How much money do you need to buy this car?
> The answer is zero.
> You borrow $10k.
> Buy the car.
> Sell the car in parts on eBay to pay back the debt.
> Car parts have no influence (with exceptions and edge cases) on a car's value.
The fact that you can take out a loan to buy something, and turn around and liquidate the parts of that thing to pay back the loan does not mean the thing has no value.
Buying a Honda Civic is buying an asset which has intrinsic value, and can be used to generate value beyond the $ price.
Buying cash gives you no additional value.
So trust me, the amount of cash does not change Enterprise Value.
If you don't believe me, read any valuation materials, such as Damodaran's.
If you want to argue that there is no value in taking over a company for its cash, sure. If you want to argue that the market sees no value in cash, no.
Now, let us say the business issues a special Dividend of $10B. Can we all agree that a rational investor, on the ex-date, would now only spend $1B on this company, instead of $11B?