Gawker owns Gizmodo and has a vested interest in painting Peter Thiel in a bad light since he has contributed to the legal expenses of their victims, so I'm unconvinced of the newsworthiness of this piece.
That doesn't make the headline any less accurate.
Zuckerberg voted to keep others on the board, too. It's routine. This isn't news. It's a swipe.
The TechCrunch headline is "Peter Thiel was not kicked off Facebook’s board" which is actually worse than Gizmodo's headline.