Seriously, equipment has been marked ON and OFF for a hundred years. Is there any evidence anyone was confused with this more than with O and | ?
Seriously, equipment has been marked ON and OFF for a hundred years. Is there any evidence anyone was confused with this more than with O and | ?
Stop is a word in Dutch (the first recognisable use of the word I could find dates back to 1287). And German has stopf. I couldn't find a date for that, because my German isn't good enough to read their etymology dictionary, but it's source is Old High Germanic, so it's safe to say that stop has been around in continental Europe in Germanic languages since Medieval time at the very least.
Edit: A quick further Google search reveals that Norwegian and Danish (and thus most likely Sweden too) have the variation "stoppe" derived from Low German.
Seems a bit disingenuous to claim it was adopted despite "not being an existing word" if two languages use the exact rendering on the sign and 4 others use/have words that are so closely related that they have the same spelling, but 1 or 2 additional letters.
Further edit: French apparently adopted the word stop from English...in 1792
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stop_sign#Stop_signs_around_th... shows examples of "Stop" used in Germany and Italy in the 1950s.
The German Wikipedia, at https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stoppschild , gives an example of "stop" used in the Protectorate of Bohemia and Moravia (after the German occupation of Czechoslovakia) in 1939, though it says the sign was an imported variant.
https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/stoppen#German points out:
> As in Dutch stoppen, the sense “to stop” is figurative from water flow being stopped by plugging. Only in this figurative meaning has the form been adopted into standard German proper, under the reinforcing influence of English to stop.
https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/stop gives a list of continental European languages where 'stop' is part of the language. Nearly all borrow from the English. Not Dutch, however.
I wouldn't underestimate the influence on the language of the American occupation after the war, either, nor the global influence of American business since the war. English words have crept in everywhere.
I figured that politics was the case. What is less supportable is working backwards from that to concoct a rational reason. People who understand digital electronic conventions are highly unlikely to not recognize "ON" and "OFF". Furthermore, anyone who does not know either would find "ON" just as easy to learn as "|".
(That's why I referred to "ON" as a 'glyph'.)
This has been standard practice for a long time, I'm not just making things up on the fly. BTW, SBY is a standard abbreviation for STANDBY used by the military, if space is a problem. And SBY is a lot more google-able than an icon.
Ok, here's my last argument then. It's aesthetically pleasing. I admit that's probably the weakest argument, but also the hardest to refute :)
I suspect the vertical slash | has as many lookalikes as the O, but I won't go there. I do want to mention that, as you demonstrated, the "1" that means on is more often represented as the Latin I or just a vertical stroke as in |, making it just as hard to ID as a numeral, especially if you don't know that the 1/0 are derived from the binary logic gates.
I would argue that the words "ON" and "OFF" when seen as glyphs are much less ambiguous than I/O.