The Rational Rejection of Security Advice by Users
research.microsoft.com
research.microsoft.com
...The cost-benefit tradeoff for most security advice is simply unfavorable: users are offered too little benefit for too much cost. Better advice might produce a different outcome. This is better than the alternative hypothesis that users are irrational.
It may not be in the best interest of my time, mathematically, but I won't stop examining urls. For my internet databases behind websites, I always use random strings for the name of the db, the usernames, and the passwords. I never need to type them directly, so they can be extremely complicated, long, and nearly impossible to remember.
I want to reduce the risk that someone can associate www.somesite.com with the database behind it. If they do that, then they also have to figure out the weird username and pass. but if the database behind somesite.com is somesite_db and the user is somesite_user, then I'm already in trouble. Instead, somesite.com is backed by a database called 3ksxi32kkk329 with a username of 2391kkxkw329049 and a password of asdlkfjl2k3j2ol3iosioci923002309899*7232$!939120012klk3129x9d923lsd923lse923lll212--0342lsiii
Most people elsewhere do not know how to read urls. Their cost for learning to read urls and remember how to find out where a link goes is higher than they are willing to pay and statistical more expensive than not doing so despite the risks!
True, and probably an understatement. Many people, perhaps even most of them, don't know what a URL is, let alone how to interpret its components.
These are the people whose ultimate means of navigating to something is to type its name, or something like its name, into the browser search box. Assuming they pay any attention to URLs at all, they presumably treat (e.g.) the "www.mcdonalds.com" that they see on a print ad as a special magic keyword that can be typed into Google. And so it is.
It doesn't even need to be statistical more expensive to be rational. Perhaps users may just be unable to forecast how much learning to read URLs will benefit them, and thus risk-aversion [1] prevents them from making the time investment.
[1] The use of risk-aversion on this meta-level is kind-of ironic, if you don't look too close.
The person to innovate in a way that capitalizes on this research is going to make a lot of money.
Isn't this the very definition of `capitalize'?