1. Both Mercurial and Git use the same history model; both have DAGs and changesets.
2. The dirstate is an internal format, and it's analogous to Git's index. You are right though, that Git allows you to manage it manually is a big difference from Mercurial.
I think Mercurial tends to be more conservative in what it allows; it discourages history editing, and it tries to be similar to Subversion and CVS in terms of UI. Git, on the other hand, provides all the power user features - like commit amendment, rebasing, and index management - up front.