Eh, more like "stop forcing people to like the things you like" christianity was undoubtedly coerced upon them
Your second comment is dead-on, not sure why it's getting downvoted. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Religion_in_Kiribati However, Christianity does not really give a reason for them to stay. I suspect it's just an excuse not to face up to the truth. If they stuck to Bahá'í (which was invented in 1844 and introduced to the island in the early 1900's) they would probably have had the same reaction.
The incidents described at that new link are certainly regrettable, however the discussion above seemed to concern the actions of Christian missionaries in the nineteenth century, not random Catholic Kiribatis in the 1950s. It's not as though Bahá'í was a native religion of Kiribati.
It might have been coerced on their great grandparents. Everyone living was born into a mostly Christian population.
They presumably would react to your assertion that they should go back to selected beliefs of their ancestors much the same way that you would react if someone demanded that you do the same.