- the whole point of startups is to test high-risk ideas in the crucible of the market. This approach promotes highly risk-averse behavior (since the penalty for failure is getting expelled from the country, along with your family).
- you're replacing a market test with bureaucratic criteria. What does it mean to create five full-time jobs? Can I hire five people the week before the deadline? Can I fire them the week after?
- The proposal badly skews the relationship between investor and entrepreneur. Since the entrepreneur's immigration status is conditional on receiving funding, the investor has essentially received a free subsidy from the government, and holds all the cards in the relationship.
- Competitors without startup visa founders know what targets the startup must meet, and can undercut them in order to sabotage their ability to meet the visa test.
I'm sure others can think of many ways this system can be gamed. The more philosophical objection is that the proposal runs against the basic ideas of a startup - high-risk, high-reward activity, low bureaucratic overhead, a tolerance for repeated failure, and the market as the ultimate arbiter of success.
The bill is well-intentioned, but displays a striking level of naivete with regard to people's behavior, and a blithe disregard for the pressures around obtaining and keeping legal residency.
The right way to achieve these goals is through comprehensive immigration reform that makes it easier to work legally in the country, acknowledging the economic contribution of millions of undocumented immigrants at every level of the economic ladder.