A "GMO free" label doesn't tell you what hasn't changed, it only tells you (assuming that the standards are clear enough that it tells you anything at all) one mechanism by which change was not introduced.
Producers of food products may benefit in many ways and the consumer may benefit from a lower price and sure in other ways, but the consumer may suffer "because GMO" (not saying this is true, but this is the popular objection to GMO). Hence, the non-GMO label makes sense because it informs the consumer of something actionable that they want to know about, which otherwise they cannot easily reason about.
A great example of this is: how many people really know that oats are never today GMO? The label isn't useful because oats aren't typically GMO, but rather because people don't readily know this -- and consumers want a direct answer to their call to know if this mechanism is at work in their food.
And again, this is not because consumers know for a fact that GMO is harmful, but rather because they perceive it as a poignant risk to their health.
Placebo effect has a negative twin in nocebo [1].
Oatmeal is not defined by lack of GMO.
Labeling deviation from what came before and is widely expected to be the case now is the heuristic I have in mind.
- If soy-free is reasonably expected to be the case then I'm suggesting no label. - If gluten free is reasonably expected to be the case the I'm suggesting no gluten-free label.
Salmonella free makes for a different case. Presence of salmonella is not likely to be a feature for anyone. Therefore, it's reasonably expected to NEVER be present and so, don't require a label.