Just click on this link and see what you get: http://duckduckgo.com/?q=the+world%27s+oldest+civilization
Google has been around for 15 years. They come from a country that is 230 years old -- and is dying.
People aren't rational. People do stupid stuff all the time and while I agree that putting people in prison for talking about stuff is harsh (the U.S. does it too), china must keep much worse things from happening to protect the lives of over a billion people.
They've been doing it successfully for thousands of years and it seems quite arrogant and ignorant to suggest that it is a good idea for some punk from across the pond to set the level of discourse necessary for China to continue operating effectively.
If you want to see what "open communication" provides, just look at the U.S. Did open communication stop an illegal war in Iraq? Did it prevent the destruction of our 200 year old constitutional rights? Did it stop a dotcom bubble or a housing bubble or a gold bubble? Has it promoted a study of history or learning or rational thought? No.
It is really beyond me why people from America, one of the biggest pilferers in the world, murderers in the world, and secretive organizations in the world would expect that increasing anything in china the way google is trying to do will lead to something good. It hasn't led to something good in the U.S. It's led to misery, suffering, and global catastrophe.
China is going to squash google like the little bug they are.