Space Emerging from Quantum Mechanics
preposterousuniverse.com
preposterousuniverse.com
Unfortunately together with the success of perturbative quantum gravity [2], this suggests that quantum gravity is just not experimentally accessible. (That's a thought by Freeman Dyson originally.) The formal argument would be, that a lot of different theories lead to the same thermodynamical limit, so that one can not determine the true underlying theory. Or put it in more hacker news terms, the problem is analogous to trying to learn about TCP/IP by looking at the output of black hole simulations, there is the layer of numerical mathematics in between, which is at least very hard to breach.
[1] Older guestpost by Grant Remmen on Carroll's blog: http://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2016/02/08/guest-po...
[2] For this discussion, it is basically cheating. You quantize gravitational waves on a classical background geometry. The approach works very well because gravity is weak, it also tells us nothing interesting, because one breaks the relationship between gravity and space time (the central feature of General Relativity) by hand.
* -* "Or, more accurately but less evocatively, “find gravity inside quantum mechanics.” Rather than starting with some essentially classical view of gravity and “quantizing” it, we might imagine starting with a quantum view of reality from the start, and find the ordinary three-dimensional space in which we live somehow emerging from quantum information."
- "If we perturb the state a little bit, how does the emergent geometry change? (Answer: space curves in response to emergent mass/energy, in a way reminiscent of Einstein’s equation in general relativity.)
It’s that last bit that is most exciting, but also most speculative."
- "But the devil is in the details, and there’s a long way to go before we can declare victory."
- "In some sense, we’re making this proposal a bit more specific, by giving a formula for distance as a function of entanglement. "
- "We’re quick to admit that what we’ve done here is extremely preliminary and conjectural. We don’t have a full theory of anything, and even what we do have involves a great deal of speculating and not yet enough rigorous calculating."
* -* "Perhaps the most interesting and provocative feature of what we’ve done is that we start from an assumption that the degrees of freedom corresponding to any particular region of space are described by a finite-dimensional Hilbert space."
- "A finite-dimensional Hilbert space describes a very different world indeed. In many ways, it’s a much simpler world — one that should be easier to understand. We shall see"
My 1 cent:
I don't know enough about this subject but...it's this creative thinking that is desperately needed in the sciences. I'm not trying to tear down others but instead just say that this is what happens when education advances. When enough (abstract) people focus on a subject, we will find a breakthrough.
Quantum mechanics seems to be how the universe really works. Outrageous predictions of quantum mechanics, from the two-slit experiment onward, have been experimentally verified. So it's a sound base for further work. Physics has been stuck for a century trying to reconcile relativity and quantum mechanics. This might be a way forward.
It might even lead to something that's experimentally verifiable.
The seeding work on this theory was published as early as 1967 and 1978.
Publication into arXiv is too restricted, because of the endorser requirement, for the article to be published there.
The subject is not controversial. The theory is just revolutionary. It require to accept the hypothesis of quantum of measurable length. The quantum of length a is assumed to be 0 in actual general relativity and quantum mechanics. In STQ the quantum length a is assumed to be different of 0. This has huge implications. It allows to explain all elementary particles, their properties and possible interactions. The standard model is an empirical model that only includes what has been seen in experiments. STQ explains everything and can thus describe what has not yet been seen like Dark Matter. It explains its nature and describes its properties like the possible interactions.
So quantification of space and time is not a new idea and there is already a sound theory built on it. My biased opinion is that it describes the real thing. This theory is not to be confused with a voxel like quantization of space.
Publishing on arXiv boils down to find an endorser. A.Meessen has the academic credentials, but this is not enough. However I agree that it is easier than publishing in a peer review journal.
Does this means that gravitation "force" can be actually just a function of entanglement (between regions of space, particles, etc.)?
http://www.nature.com/ncomms/journal/v3/n10/full/ncomms2076....
I've long thought this would be a good way to go for research. I once had a crack at understanding Feynman's arguments that you could get general relativity from spin-2 particle theory in the book Lectures on Gravitation based on his 1965 lectures with the intention of writing a simplified version for Wikipedia. I failed - too hard - maybe someone else can do a laymans version? As far as I know there hasn't been very much progress since Feynman's attempts which were not renormalizable.