This is a weird critique of R-Squared. You (should) learn very early on that comparing R-Squared values of different models is a no-no.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Coefficient_of_determination#I...
Also, I find that the OP is actually more confusing on this topic than Wikipedia.
Not sure how else I can support that this is a basic fact about this metric. I'm not in the mood to find quotes in intro textbooks, etc.