At least we're consistent.
I have very little patience for people who are tired of the conversation that we never seem to have. There are no women in this industry. It's unnatural, it's stifling, and it's a problem. And I think it's a situation where the wolf is guarding the hen-house -- the chickens keep disappearing, but nobody knows why! Whatever could it be?
One thing I've noticed amongst my female friends is that while they might get interviews, they tend to be rejected at a much higher rate than equally qualified male applicants. Given how completely idiotic and machismo-driven the interview process is at most tech companies, it wouldn't surprise me at all to find out that this is an industry-wide phenomenon.
Do I know this is a problem? No. But like most other latent sources of bias, we'll never know if we stick our heads in the sand every time the subject is raised.
In any case, at least you're trying to hire more women. That's more than can be said for the guys who respond to every thread with the comment equivalent of a shrug. The voting trends here are also indicative: nearly any comment that dismisses or diminishes the solvability of the problem is voted up; all others are ignored or voted down.
(Disclaimer: I'm a man, but I know a lot of female engineers. I obviously can't speak for all of them, but I've noticed some trends.)
Many women in engineering are wary of situations in which they won't be taken seriously.
For example: say there's one guy on your team who tends to patronize women, especially ones he finds attractive. He might not realize he does this. You have a female engineer who's getting fed up with this behavior, and tries to gently (because she's experienced this before) point this out. He gets defensive -- maybe he says she IS different than the other engineers, so it's only natural, maybe he just gets angry, whatever -- but, whatever he does, it's not an honest effort to improve. Later, she tries to bring this up with someone else on the team, look for help, but to everyone else he's always been a nice guy, so why is she making trouble?
Or let's say someone illustrates a presentation with some unfortunate images or metaphors. (Where have we seen this before?) Nothing flagrantly unconscionable, but, you know, kind of skirting the edge of acceptability. This makes a female engineer uncomfortable -- the presentation marginalizes her, makes her wonder if the team sees her as a colleague or an object of desire. Now, she knows it's going to end badly, but she mentions that it made her uncomfortable, and asks that everyone please try to avoid that mode of presentation in the future. And suddenly everyone on the team is explaining, no, he didn't mean in THAT way, the presentation wasn't REALLY about her -- well, if you hadn't marginalized her before, now you definitely have.
It doesn't have to be that way. But in some places, it is. I've talked to women looking for software engineering jobs, and this is definitely something that gets considered. Are other women willing to work there? Willing to stay? Will they have anyone to back them up when shit happens? Because when the answer is "no", life sucks.
That said, I don't know how you hire the first one. But you've got to be aware of these things. You've got to make completely sure that you look like someplace where women will be respected and taken seriously, not marginalized and undermined. Because, if a good female candidate gets a whiff of that, she's probably gone.
But you're right, I should have a better answer to this question. I should discuss it with my friends sometime and try to get a handle on it.
Get to know some female engineers, if you don't already. Not necessarily as potential hires, but as professional contacts. At that point, they may decide they're interested in the jobs you have, or they may know women who are. If they refer female candidates to you, their implicit endorsement will help your credibility. It will be very hard to hire female engineers if you don't know any.
Oddly enough, most men applying for the job want to have some assurance that they're going to be respected and their concerns taken seriously. Having someone of the same sex as you on a team or at the workplace is no assurance of anything.
Also, lots of men get put off by immature attributes about sex, and a company the fosters a culture similar to a high school boys locker room is going to loose both men and women who don't care for that.
I mean, you hardly need a locker room atmosphere to turn women away. Plenty of little things can contribute. Maybe you have a guy who constantly fawns over one particular coworker. Maybe the team has grown to expect that the women will bring the bagels on Friday mornings. Maybe the labels "emotional" or "too sensitive" stick a little too easily. Maybe t-shirts at work events only tend to show up in men's M-XL. Maybe another group tends to explain things to the new female engineer in very small words, implicitly not acknowledging her as a peer. Whatever.
Here's the thing: you need to be sure that the women in your workplace are comfortable telling you these things. As a man, it can be hard to realize that there are problems when the work environment is 90% men. Why? Because you're not on the receiving end of all the bullshit, most of the stereotypes and cultural norms work in your favor, and most of the people you know are the same way. Very few men are thinking, "man, I wish I could make women feel unvalued." Most of the toxic behavior happens out of apathy or ignorance.
But, even then, most little problems, in isolation, are just that: little problems in search of solutions. Unfortunately, when women do speak up, what they often hear is, "I don't see the problem. That's never happened to me. I think you're overreacting." That response is, I would venture, why having another woman on the team is reassuring: because she probably would see the problem, it probably has happened to her. That response is why women in engineering want to know they'll have someone (male or female) willing to back them up, or at least to listen: because they're used to having to go it alone.
How do they all know that it was specifically because they are women?
In other words: because most of these things don't apply to men. And because, when women try to explain what's happening, one of the most frequent reactions they get from men is, "what are you talking about?" (Or the related, "oh, but that happens to me too," followed by a spurious equivalence.)
So, look, if you really want to get into the details, there's a limit to what I can tell you. I'm male, so I'm not speaking from my own experience. If you're genuinely curious, ask some female engineers. Not all of them will feel the way I've described, but I've talked to enough to know that I'm not totally off-base. The main thing is, if you want to know, you have to be willing to actually listen and accept that they have had experiences different from yours. Even if you disagree with them, try to hold off on going into debate mode; they've probably done that too many times before and are tired of it.
I'm assuming what you're saying is if you instead say 'ok, we won't do that' she won't assume (based on the lack of protest) that it was in fact objectifying her?
And how is it saying the presentation wasn't objectifying you marginalizing? 'You aren't important enough to objectify'? Psychology... it confuses me. I never understand how people don't want to be objectified yet seem to be offended if you don't want to objectify them. It's like, 'I want you to want to, but I don't want you to actually do it'...
And for your second paragraph: saying "no, it's not like that" is marginalizing because it demonstrates an unwillingness to take the woman seriously. If she says, "I didn't like that, it made me feel excluded from the group", and you say, "well, we didn't mean it that way": you are continuing to exclude her. The message communicated is, "your opinions aren't important". If the presentation went so far as to be objectifying, you're saying "well, I didn't mean for it to make you feel objectified, so you shouldn't feel that way" -- which indicates a flagrant lack of respect.
For emphasis: I do not know a single female engineer (not a single engineer, actually) who wants to be sexually objectified by his or her peers. Not one. They want to be respected as competent engineers, as colleagues, as friends.
"Sexual objectification refers to the practice of regarding or treating another person merely as an instrument (object) towards the person's sexual pleasure."
I don't know of anyone who wants this in the context of work. Even if they're, say, attracted to someone else on the team: they're still not interested in being reduced to only the sexual aspect of their being.
As for the last bit, sorry if I wasn't clear, I'm fully aware of that. I was just confused as logic seemed to imply you were in fact stating that the woman would want to be wanted, and I didn't believe it.
I am also generally a little confused because my reaction would be "I'm sorry! We didn't mean it that way. It won't happen again." Is that also wrong?
In my experience, which spans 2 companies having what I judge to be remarkable software engineering talent, several women at each place feature prominently on the "lifeboat list". At each of those places, the stars had a much higher percentage of women than the general population at those places (though still short of 50/50). Said slightly differently, given you were a woman at one of those places, you were disproportionately likely to be a star.
If far fewer women than men enter computer science (at the university level), I don't think that it's likely that workplace discrimination effects are the dominant effects in the final population biases we all see. It's also no surprise to see that those who do enter are disproportionately good, because they are disproportionately likely to be intrisincally more motivated and interested in the work than the large set of "unwashed masses [of males]" who enter comp-sci because it's a relatively easy way to make a comfortable and secure living, even if they don't really "care" about it.
I know for my own account, I'll hire every qualified candidate I can find, without regard to gender or anything else unrelated to their prospective job performance. As I think back to the college recruiting I've done for my current firm, I can think of 2 men whose candidacy I championed significantly and 3 women in that same boat. That's against a candidate pool that is probably >5:1::male:female ratio.
Besides, it just makes me feel guilty for being one of the awkward teenagers who reinforced the stereotype that math and science are for unattractive, unpopular, socially retarded people. Who knows, I may have personally turned a few women away from technical fields by being the shining, shambling, pimply, slack-jawed, poorly-dressed, sex-obsessed, socially blunderous face of math and science at my school. Damage done. WTF can I do about it now? Treat female candidates who have already entered the profession fairly? That's easy (if you have a consistent and systematic interview process) and also not particularly useful for improving the demographics of the profession.
My theory is that regular computer science and programming education for all students starting in the 5th or 6th grade would balance it out a bit.
Why does women's intolerance of people like you make you feel guilty?
What next, should Indians/Asians feel guilty for driving racists out of computing? Making computing unattractive to intolerant people is a good thing.
"I may have personally turned a few women away from technical fields by being the shining, shambling, pimply...face of math and science at my school."
Similarly, I don't blame all whites if a few of them avoid computing in a effort not to talk to minorities, just the intolerant ones. And in my opinion, we are better off without them.
In any case, I believe dkarl was trying to be funny, and you've twisted that into something fairly ugly.
Similarly, a woman is free to be intolerant of geeks, but no geek should feel guilty for driving her out of computing. Her avoidance of computing is caused by her own intolerance, nothing more.
I'm saying that as someone who works as a programmer, what can I really do, other than be cognizant of the problem and, when the opportunity presents itself, first do no harm, and hopefully do a bit of good?
I think the real reason the women aren't infiltrating the male dominated industry is because they are letting themselves be to dependent on the status quo.