One small example: someone could delete that github repository, and you'd be hosed. But many centralized systems (like crates.io) do not let you remove packages. The only way that things accidentally break there is if the government gets involved.
As a package user you could use your own git mirroring server or just use a fork. Even simpler just vendor it and you are safe from package removal. On the other hand a central distribution model is more problematic. As package author I want a certain degree of control over my code. If crates.io gets compromissed or is down everyone suffers. If crates.io received a DMCA(happened on npm) my package can be removed. I put some effort into that package so if for some reasons I want to remove it it should be my choice. Why do want to keep it hostage if it's not yours? I though at leat Mozilla learned that distributed is better than centralized. Do you want a place to find all the rust packages? Make a search engine(see godoc.org). Less is more!
Sure, those are all various options. I was replying specifically to "why not GitHub".
That's certainly true -- unrelated to the discovery point I mentioned, but it is true. The different tradeoffs are well-understood at this point IMO.