Show HN: Functional Programming for Kids: Interactive Tutorial
github.com
github.com
The design is also pretty cluttered -- no child under the age of 16 is going to have the patience to get through those huge walls of text.
This should really be called 'Functional Programming for Teenagers, Maybe, or College Kids Who Don't Know How to Program'.
Do any of the developers have ANY experience in childhood education at all???
Computer Programming is field of turning informal and vague declarations of a process into an infinity accurate declaration of a process. It is also the field of doing that in a simple and maintainable way.
It is as much related to spelling and literature as it is mathematics. What I think it more closely relates to is philosophy and logical analysis. I think it is also a disservice to people to wrongly inform them of what will be expected of them by saying "this field is math."
These examples probably show how little I know about children. You can probably think of some better ones.
it's nice because it starts off with a game, and walks the students through making it themselves.
strong math knowledge needed to understand it. polish notation could be also confusing.
The problem seems like the problem with Clojure (instead of say Racket) would be the uninformative error messages.
This might be good thing to discuss in a tutorial aimed at kids.
As an adult, I can only speak for myself, and although this is nice, I think it is comparable to the functional programming programs for adults out there (for instance, Microsoft's online F# tutorial, or Coursera's Scala tutorial). The pictures and things aren't making it easier for me. I don't know if it will be different for kids.
Did you try the regular "adult" tutorials with them? It would be interesting to see if they liked this more, or found one of them interesting.
One fundamental aspect of functional programing is that it specifies the use of functions as arguments.
I like the chapter suggestion. Maybe each chapter builds upon a function that the kids can relate to. The subsequent chapters can use the previous functions as "arguments" or objects so that they understand this concept.