Hacker News Reader

Comment by themihai | Hacker News Reader

Do you find using pub/extern keywords more elegant than a simple capitalization? To me rust is verbose in many cases like java with a lot keywords heading towards C++ complexity which is exactly what Go tries to avoid. I understand that now crago becomes somehow part of the language as the extern declarations will become "optional"/deprecated. So yeah, I hope Go won't adopt any of these fancy/XXI century features.

View on HN

Let me see... instead of having to capitalize every single usage of a given symbol, I can just prefix it's defintion once with `pub`? Yeap, I rather do that. Instead of replacing all instances to lower case, I can just remove the `pub`. It's obviously better.

Rust is noisy in other parts, for other reasons (trying to explain to compiler how to write super fast and data-race free code). But visibility qualifiers are not a problem.

`extern` is only for importing crates, which is like 10 lines at in whole package/crate. Irrelevant.

Just for contrast, when I'm exporting something in Go, using gorename makes it very easy to fix all the references within the package. It works the same when I'm un-exporting something as well. However, when un-exporting I have to go though all other packages that use that identifier and fix the code that used it. Presumably you need to do something similar when you remove the `pub` (i.e. It's not just a simple removing of the pub unless nothing used it to begin with).

Ultimately in the end, for this example it really seems like the same amount of work. You add one word, I run one command.

> I understand that now crago becomes somehow part of the language as the extern declarations will become "optional"/deprecated.

You are incorrect on multiple fronts - 1) there is not even an active proposal to this effect, its just an idea that was passed around and not even really discussed, 2) the idea did not involve making rustc depend on cargo at all. It would be shocking to me for the Rust community to ever accept a proposal which required rustc to depend on cargo.

In general, please try to avoid contributing to the spread of misinformation by not stating as facts things you are not very confident are true.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com