The case in question a week-long criminal trial of a police detective who tipped off a suspected child predator of his impending arrest. The charges were obstruction of justice, abuse of power and aiding in the sexual assault of a minor.
One notable difference between jury trials in Colorado and elsewhere is that Colorado gives judges the option of allowing jurors to submit their own questions of witnesses. Much of the case hinged on an email the detective had sent the child predator, so of course the defense tried to obfuscate by throwing up smoke screens to confuse the jury.
Two of us on the jury were software engineers. We were allowed to question both the defense's computer forensic expert and the state's. We were allowed to directly examine records subpoenaed from Google, Yahoo, Craigslist and various ISP's.
A Colorado jury isn't just a silent observer, we were active participants (though we never spoke—questions were written and submitted anonymously to the judge, who had discretion on which to allow, and counsel was given the chance to object to each question before it was read aloud to the witness).
In the end, we found him guilty. And I have no doubt we were correct.
"Peers" in that case, maybe should have meant "people able to understand the technicalities", engineers and software lawyers.
I'm glad you're certain in your conclusions, but in my mind there's a worry that that kind of "back-seat testimony" makes the trial less transparent and fair.
If you think that there aren't several confident know-it-all types who never get cross-examined on every jury everywhere ever, you wouldn't make a very good defense attorney.
Care to elaborate on your objections? Juries exist so that it limits the ability of the State / prosecutors or defense teams from lobbying or coercing 'professional jurors'. You do not want the people who are determining if a citizen broke a law beholden / under the thumb of the state. I say this even as someone who had a jury rule against myself in a civil case that both sides (defense and plaintiff) thought that a judge would rule in my favor.
"Oh geez you've not been chosen to sit on a jury recently, your paycheck is going to be a bit short this month. Maybe if you agreed more with the prosecutors..."
I don't buy that they will inject mercy, especially if they thought about irrelevant factors to determine guilt or innocence.
Juries are unpredictable. Does that mean that they made good judgement or that they are swayed by good-sounding arguments?
Juries are allowed to vote "Guilty" or "Not Guilty" regardless of whether they think the accused broke the law. They cannot be punished by the Court. This is all expressly designed to allow Juries to correct inevitable tragedies brought about by too-literal (or too-political) interpretation of the law. I.e., mercy.
Of course that's just one experience.
If a thousand parallel operating "magic 8 balls" provides observed pragmatically bad advice, surely a random subset of a mere twelve "magic 8 balls" will not provide usefully better advice.
By analogy, if you need a team of programmers, one ineffective way to recruit would be to visit the "CS 101 intro to hello world" lecture hall of hundreds and randomly select a dozen. Obviously the team will be a smaller subset so somehow it has to be smarter?
Another common objection, often brought up in countries without juries, is that only a guilty person would desire a jury, because unlike a judge, it could be misled by appeals to emotion and faulty legal arguments.
Juries also seem to be unnecessary, because there are plenty of countries that don't use juries and have more just and equitable legal systems than countries that do.
These aren't exactly my views, but they are common objections raised against juries.
This can also be turned around to the benefit of the prosecutor. Prosecutors may pursue legally bogus charges if they are dealing with an unsympathetic defendant. Either way, juries are more susceptible to emotional appeals than legal experts--a bad thing when the law is just, but a good thing when the law is wrong.
In the jury system, juries are charged with answering questions as to the facts, and judges are charged with answering questions as to the law. It makes full use of the judge's expertise in the law as well as a small sample of society's expertise in human nature and the human experience.
> Another common objection, often brought up in countries without juries, is that only a guilty person would desire a jury, because unlike a judge, it could be misled by appeals to emotion and faulty legal arguments.
Or put another way, someone who is technically guilty, but under circumstances where conviction of the technical violation would be unconscionable.
> Juries also seem to be unnecessary, because there are plenty of countries that don't use juries and have more just and equitable legal systems than countries that do.
Without getting into the merits of the obviously subjective argument here, it's not clear that the conclusion follows even if we grant the assumption. The superior justice system of a non-jury country might be perfected yet further by introducing juries.
Naturally, some laws will need explained simply because folks never come in need of that law. Some accounting laws, for example, would need explained to non-accountants. Explaining the difference between the different levels of murder could need explained because most of us aren't murdering folks. But it seems that should be well within the confines of the system.
>Only a guilty person would desire a jury
This would simply depend on the honesty of the system. If you are wrongly accused and offered a plea deal, you might wind up going to trial if you have a non-guilty plea. Theoretically there wouldn't be enough evidence to prosecute you, but those cases make it through nonetheless. Plus there are charges such as "visiting a common nuisance" that are difficult for folks to disprove. visiting a common nuisance is generally visiting a drug dealer or other such location, regardless of your knowledge of what was going on
http://thecriminallawyer.tumblr.com/post/16202923895/interlu...
In short, you're asking jurors to take on a huge responsibility with little to no understanding of the laws they're being expected to make a decision on. In virtually every instance the jurors are left in a completely uneducated state and unable to give any proper assessment, relying basically on whatever cues they decide to pick up on instead of factual evidence. The idea of 12 Angry Men never really existed with juries and was far outside the scope of what a juror is really supposed to be doing.
The instructions are also written by a panel of judges/lawyers so they are very methodical and logical. "In order to be convicted of murder, you must find at least one (1) of the following to be true:....".
We had testimony re-read by the reporter and all the physical evidence was just given to us to rifle through. We could replay videos, etc.
Sure it's not perfect, but it's life. What in life is perfect?
-Juries are allowed to take notes. -Juries are allowed to submit questions, that are reviewed for approval by both sides' lawyers and the judge. -Juries do get a copy of the law they need to determine was violated
Criminal and civil trial instructions for juries are drastically different. Heck, trial instructions for different issues within either domain can be drastically different, too.
Whether the defense or prosecution made mistakes, if you're left with a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty (and I personally consider it the case that inept defense can cause reasonable doubt, unless the prosecution presents an airtight case - a lot of people, including most of my lawyer friends, would disagree with me there), don't vote to convict.
That is my main problem with juries. Whatever they are, they are decidedly not a jury of my peers. They are people who are selected to be as dumb and open to suggestion as possible. Effectively a popularity contest between counsel.
One day in a courtroom during jury selection should show any thinking individual that the whole process is a complete farce. Only the least capable (in general) end up on juries - and it's entirely by design.