http://amasci.com/amateur/holo3.html
Having studied with Steve Benton at the Media Lab and built some of the highest fidelity white light 3D displays of the time, I would agree with this article: scratch holograms behave very similar to rainbow ("Benton") holograms. They use a combination of diffraction, diffusion, and parallax to produce an HPO (horizontal parallax only) 3D image.
Yes, it isn't made by interference. No, it isn't full parallax or does it form an image purely by diffraction. But a scratch hologram is the superposition of the equivalent of many zone plates, and the basic mechanics are the same as in a hologram (well, a holographic stereogram). It definitely isn't "just" parallax.
All that said, I agree that what's happening is very different from a computed hologram that models interference mathematically and records the detailed pattern on a recording material. Computing and writing such a pattern requires very high resolution to get the high spatial frequencies needed to get large diffraction angles. That makes it very tedious to make any image, and even worse one made of lots of points.
A scratch hologram (or a holographic stereogram) gets around that problem by essentially modulating details in the spatial domain (the image) onto a high frequency diffractive or diffusing carrier signal (the scratch, or a holographic diffraction pattern in a holographic stereogram).
You say "They use a combination of diffraction, diffusion, and parallax". But the source you cite says, first thing, "They employ no diffraction in reconstructing images" (quite apart from the fact that diffraction is a form of interference).
You then say "a scratch hologram is the superposition of the equivalent of many zone plates". But a zone plate, being the intersection of a planar wave and a spherical wave, only works for one wavelength. Scratch holograms have no wavelength-dependent effects. Furthermore, the geometry isn't even the same - in a zone plate, the ring spacing gets smaller as you get further from the center. This is not the case with the curved scratches on a scratch hologram: http://amasci.com/graphics/swatch.gif. And it's perfectly clear why - it's not about wave interference, but about maintaining curvature. It's much more akin to a fresnel lens.
So, unless I'm missing something deep, zone plates and interference etc are a total red herring and not useful to understanding scratch holography at all.
A Benton white light hologram is composed of narrow horizontal slices of zoneplates, one for each reconstructed point. Something like this:
http://amasci.com/graphics/swatch.gif
My insight was this: if the above zoneplate-slice is squared off and increased in spatial frequency, it still reconstructs the same 3D image point. If we drew the nested fringes of that above zoneplate by scratching with a needle, it still produces the same glowing pixel floating in space.
In other words, white-light holograms are frequency-independent, just as always claimed. Yes, if we change the frequency of the above zoneplate pattern, the rainbow coloration will shift, and may even appear white. Yet the reconstructed 3D image remains unaltered. The 3D image data is not contained in the spacing of the interference fringes. That's another way to say that the hologram still functions even if the spacing between fringes is randomized.
It even keeps working if all fringes but one are removed.
Here's the relationship between the zoneplates of Benton holograms, versus the 'zoneplates' of scratch holograms:
http://amasci.com/graphics/holo/onestp2.gif
Benton white-light holograms only use interference to record their zoneplates. They don't use interference to reconstruct the 3D image. (That's why they still function under white-light illumination.)
Or, here's another approach. Benton holograms and scratch holograms are based on Poisson's Spot. They don't act like a fresnel lens, instead they act like a conical lens, causing an incoming beam to both converge and scatter into a long locus with no focal point. The "facets" of Benton holograms and scratch holograms need no be diffraction patterns or prisms, they can be random striations, parallel fibers, narrow cylinder lenses, reflective wires, etc.
It's perfectly OK to insist that scratch holograms aren't genuine holograms. But to remain honest and consistent, we're also then forced to declare that Benton holograms aren't true holograms.
Or, as I said in the linked articles, the bench setup for making Benton white-light holograms is actually an optical device for producing entire scratch holograms all at once, with no individual scratching needed.
Heh, "metal rods are the interference fringes!" needs quotation marks, since I guess it wasn't obvious that I was being silly.
[Are these REALLY holograms?](http://amasci.com/amateur/holo3.html)
But it's unfair to say all white-light holograms aren't holograms. A normal Denisyuk reflection hologram made with lasers and everything will replay perfectly well under a halogen lamp.
If you made a scratch hologram, but your compass-point had a small cluster of fifty tiny needles instead of a single big needle, that comes close to the fringe-structure of Benton white-light holograms.
:)
> But it's unfair to say all white-light holograms aren't holograms
True. By "white light" I was referring to Rainbow / credit-card / Benton holograms.
http://www.holoeast.com/holography/holograms_maiking.html
Inspired by the process for creating compact disks, stamped holograms took Benton's rainbow holograms and made them cheaply reproducible through a mechanical process. Mike Foster developed the process and Steve McGrew made it commercially viable.
Other types of white light holograms, such as the two-step "rainbow" white light transmission hologram that Steve Benton created or the white light reflection hologram of Yuri Denisyuk are both holograms proper -- they are both made using a traditional holographic process.
A transmission white light hologram has less controllable color because it uses broad spectrum diffraction. A white light reflection hologram uses a thick diffraction pattern to additionally filter white light down to a narrow spectrum, producing a more pure color. Full color reflection holograms can be produced by superimposing multiple diffractive patterns in the hologram layer, one for each primary color.