Tons of stuff is classified, sits in a safe for years and years, and eventually just gets shredded. Probably 99.99% of it. There is a cost to declassify documents, but for the mountains of stuff that never gets declassified (because it just goes into the memory black hole) there is no cost.
Honestly I think there is just a CYA mentality to just slap SECRET on documents rather than trying to thread the needle and figure out the exact correct classification. In theory these documents should be classified at the paragraph level, and in that case things like public statements by public figures would be unclassified even if they were a part of a highly classified document.
People will properly classify things if there is some reason to, but day to day it's not trivial to do and in the end nobody sees their goal as 'get the exact right classification on everything' vs 'find a terrorist or figure out what russia is planning'.