For Photographers, the Image of a Shrinking Path
nytimes.com
nytimes.com
An interesting re-occurrence of Steve Martin's observation in a recently posted article:
"[It] was easy to be great. Every entertainer has a night when everything is clicking. These nights are accidental and statistical: like lucky cards in poker, you can count on them occurring over time. What was hard was to be good, consistently good, night after night, no matter what the circumstances."
You still might not pick an amateur photo for a calendar, but you'd probably pick it for a background in an ad.
Note also that not all pro work is concentrated around difficult shots or situations. Gabe Rivera of Techmeme tweeted a few weeks ago about Agence France-Presse flying a professional photographer out to the U.S. to shoot him as part of an interview package. The photo they used online? His hand holding a mouse:
http://www.google.com/hostednews/afp/article/ALeqM5jj324Ei1-...
The thousand-amateurs argument is like the argument that the world doesn't need professional developers, any amateur can build their own apps with Excel and Access...
A pro landscape photographer will plan their shoot: weather, sunrise/set, times, directions. And then they'll wait, try, fail, try, fail, kinda succeed... and then come away a completely different shot ;-) Apparently, it's 50% planned shot / 50% unplanned (but discovered during a planned/failed shot)
I hope Shutter Scouts can make it easier for enthusiasts and professional alike to make the most of their time by pointing them in the right direction, at the right time, for their most promising ideas.
This of course doesn't work if you absolutely must have photos of some particular event, so there will always be room for professionals even if they're squeezed.
* Other pros that I took work from were often jerks. Being a nice, direct and reasonable individual takes you a long way in that business.
* Being professional meant having a studio, quoting and billing clearly, being a good communicator with clients. Things amateur shoots don't always do well.
* Being consistent in terms of quality, turn around time, etc.
There is still work out there if you have a stable of good clients that need and value the above. But in cases where stock photos will do, you're screwed.
This means that amateur photographers in many cases can do just as good a job as a professional. It's pretty much the same reason why magazines and newspapers are declining, the internet and social networks have lead to a democratization of news.
To be successful as a professional photographer, you have to offer more than what amateurs are capable of, and in addition be able to educate your customer why you're worth the extra cash. As always, it's about staying competitive, instead of weeping over the past.
There is still a business of stock photos for people that want it. You just have to know what the market wants - and it isn't another misty dawn view of the Golden Gate.
What's next? Software? 3D models?
What you see happening is producers competing against all other producers in their field, past and present.
Uniqueness, originality and authenticity become the premium values for any creative work.
I have nothing against Deviant Art or Etsy or SupermarketHQ or any other site to buy great art for the artists, but don't discount the local artists.
I'm not saying artists shouldn't be paid, but when I cannot tell the difference between a $20 print from Target or a $500 print by some unknown artists that I bought off the wall of a coffee shop, I'm probably going to either just go for $20 thing, or spend $50 and print some of my friends' photos.
But I would hope there are local artists with more reasonably priced artwork.
My wife is a photographer/artist so I have become very familiar with the local art scene in Minneapolis and have gotten my hands on some great art. Some pricey, some very cheap.
I have had quite a few sneers and emails complaining about ruining their livelihoods because I give stuff away for free, I found it pretty strange, like me going to github and complaining about these programmers giving stuff away.
( * http://www.flickr.com/photos/daleharvey/collections/72157600... my music stuff)
I was in a band in the 1990s and remember hiring some photojournalist friends of mine to take our publicity and live photos. We paid the equivalent of $50 for a few rolls (it was overseas) but I remember in the end we or some friends started doing it for us for free. Kind of wish Flickr had been around then, maybe we could have gotten some useful shots from a wider range of people and cameras.
Interesting article, but I doubt professional photographers have much to worry about. The amateur will fill a niche, perhaps compete with the low-end of the spectrum of professional photographers, but - ultimately - the kind of image licensing that nets the most cash, and makes the most careers, is celebrity and high end editorial.
This strikes me as the market realizing that, when they just need a photo, there's plenty out there. For cases where a professional is needed, say for a photo shoot, professionals are still hired. Most of the rest of this seems like an increase in stock photo use (which was previously unfairly snubbed) combined with the economy troubles. It's happening everywhere, photography isn't alone in this.
Pages are at a premium, and there’s more competition to get anything into a magazine now, and the bar is just higher for excellent work.
Is this somehow a bad thing? Lack of competition to improve may very well have caused this whole trend.
More photographers = more competition (if you're also a photographer) OR a bigger market (if you sell to photographers)
which would you choose? I'm an enthusiast photographer but have no intention of going down the pro route. Instead, I'm building http://shutterscouts.com -- an idea notebook and weather forecasting service for landscape photographers. Just went live for beta this week!