If you have 24 kids total in the district, then maybe you put them all in one classroom regardless of age and teach that way. If you have 300 kids in the school district now you can do separate classes for each age. If you have 900 kids, now each grade can have 3 classes and maybe one of them in each grade can be set aside for advanced students and one for slower students. If you have 25,000 kids in the district, now you can start doing things like an entire G&T school, and/or a school for the students interested in performing arts, and/or a specialized vocational high school.
Unfortunately, the trend in the US is towards micro-catchment areas mostly as a legacy of racial segregation efforts and because of the continuing desire to have socio-economic segregation.
In third grade, I was in a mixed third/fourth grade classroom. It may have been the least boring year I spent in elementary school, although frankly that isn't a high bar to clear.
The school is 500' away. Now, his son is too young to just walk on his own, but that's a couple of minutes to get him to school.
When I was in high school (early 00s) my school was 1.7 miles, had to walk further than 500' to get to the city bus stop (or just walk/bike).