Here is a simple model a mathematician might realistically use to model this. Given N traders, let P_1..P_N be iid Beta(α, β), and let the chance that trader n loses money during a year be Bernoulli(P_n). The nice thing about this more complicated model is that the simpler model is a limit case of it.
This "first approximation" lets us use simple mathematical tools to test hypotheses like that by providing an alternative model. If our beta distribution looks more like a constant distribution (with high values for α and β) then we can conclude that the number of traders who lose money approaches 100% as time goes on. If the estimate for α and β is lower, we might reasonably conclude that there is some factor of skill involved.
This is just one possible model you could use to test if there is skill involved in day trading. There are many other models which we could test which would also mean that the proportion does not approach 100%, such as a models which assume correlations between different years.
>only 80% of them lose money over one year, but as time continues over multiple years, the percent [that loses some] money approaches 100%.
How does your model account for magnitude?
The model I gave was the simplest model I could think of that would let you test the theory that skill is a factor in day trading. It was an illustration of how someone with mathematical training might think about statistics like "80% of day traders lose money" without jumping to the false conclusion that all traders eventually lose money.
Got anything to back up this "fact"?
> The model I gave was the simplest model I could think of that would let you test the theory that skill is a factor in day trading.
You can't assume the existence of skill proves the existence of long-term profits.
Nor can you even assume that a good up/down ratio proves skill without considering the magnitude of the ups and downs or the impact of compounding.