Some good analysis. I find that for me, flying as a mode of transportation is never discretionary -- I need to get across the US in less-than-three-or-four days to attend a multi-day event, business or leisure, so every other form of transportation is out -- so to start every trip with a bad cross-continental flight is a sure recipe for an awful time.
Luckily, I can afford a slightly higher economy fare in exchange for lowering -- but not eliminating -- my risk of an unpleasant flight.