How does your model account for magnitude?
The model I gave was the simplest model I could think of that would let you test the theory that skill is a factor in day trading. It was an illustration of how someone with mathematical training might think about statistics like "80% of day traders lose money" without jumping to the false conclusion that all traders eventually lose money.
Got anything to back up this "fact"?
> The model I gave was the simplest model I could think of that would let you test the theory that skill is a factor in day trading.
You can't assume the existence of skill proves the existence of long-term profits.
Nor can you even assume that a good up/down ratio proves skill without considering the magnitude of the ups and downs or the impact of compounding.