We could do something that would actually work: Deregulate the industry, enhance legal protection for healthcare workers (to keep the lawyers from driving prices up again). Let health insurers decide rates and demographics they wish to cover. Legalize discounts for people with healthy habits, and penalties for those who don't have them. And instead of trying to tax the health insurance companies into covering people with expensive health conditions, we could actually fund medicare (instead of both Democrats and Republicans continuously slashing it's payments to healthcare workers). Competition for the "healthy" people would stabilize quickly and insurance companies would be forced to grow profits by creating plans individualised for not so healthy people. Really the only regulation needed would be ones around a couple of moral issues, maybe something like: no dropping people for health conditions that aren't preventable... or have different classes of insurance like the do in the auto industry.
One only has to look at how competitive the life insurance market to see this work in action right now. Even with someone that has COPD can get affordable life insurance with after a health screening.