More competition results in a worse functioning market. Therefore for ideal outcomes you don't create separate insurers, and no one moves out.
My question isn't on the economics, to be honest. My question is on the weird cultural idiosyncrasy. I don't really understand that (and by that I mean I understand its "political", but the math and success of it is pretty clear, so how is the topic successfully made confusing).
That's the real magic at play, and thats what I'd like insight about.